News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s Nest will provide data to police without a warrant by delecti on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:46AM (#32251039)
I'd find this much more acceptable if the system told people when their data was provided to police without a warrant. There's less potential for abuse if they're transparent about it.
Re:Google’s Nest will provide data to police without a warrant by ajross on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:50AM (#32251094)
Then you might want to read the linked article and not the headline, because CNET asked that question and... got an affirmative response, that Google will try to notify users whose data has been shared.

Really almost all the top comments on this topic are people overreacting to the headline without realizing that the circumstances involved are emergencies and not just routine LE requests. Clickbait has ruined everything.

Re:Google’s Nest will provide data to police without a warrant by yardie on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:00AM (#32251269)
> the circumstances involved are emergencies and not just routine LE requests.

Fine, every routine LE request is now an emergency. Because one thing US LEOs are known for is their reserve in only requesting just the absolute minimum to do an investigation.

Re:Google’s Nest will provide data to police without a warrant by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:58AM (#32251234)
Try.

They'll try to notify users? After their data has been shared with police.

Well that's reassuring.

Re:Google’s Nest will provide data to police without a warrant by shadowgovt on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:01PM (#32252157)
Consider the circumstances. The context in which this data is shared is imminent danger to life. That includes kidnapping.

If Google had a magic system for getting information to a kidnapping victim reliably, they wouldn't need to share user's private data with law enforcement, they could just share the information on where to reach the kidnap victim.

Re:Google’s Nest will provide data to police without a warrant by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:26PM (#32255495)
You don't fool me.

What this will predominantly be used for is abusive partners, who also happen to be law enforcement officers (police) to terrorise their victims, or, more generally, abuse of powers by LE.

Here in Australia the police already have 30% more domestic violence charges than the average, and have been caught way too many times abusing their powers as LE.

Re:Google’s Nest will provide data to police without a warrant by jollybean on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:24PM (#32260154)
This was used 7 times in the USA. 7.

Also, a cop doing this would leave a trail of evidence of their irrefutable guilt.

You're being hyperbolic.

Re:Google’s Nest will provide data to police without a warrant by trasz on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @12:23PM (#32252512)
>The context in which this data is shared is imminent danger to life.

Not at all - it's merely somebody's _claim_ that there's some danger.

Re:Google’s Nest will provide data to police without a warrant by shadowgovt on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:05PM (#32255144)
A subpoena is based on merely somebody's claim that there's reasonable suspicion of a crime. All this policy by Google does is shift the set of people who are making the decision of what "reasonable suspicion" looks like; one's reaction to that depends on one's relative threat models of judges (and time delay of interacting with judges) vs. Google employees.

FWIW, anyone still doing business with Google probably has a relatively high trust of Google, so that comparison is probably closer to equivalent than many might imagine for Google's users.

Re:Google’s Nest will provide data to police without a warrant by turdit on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:59AM (#32251250)
in 1984, it’s an emergency if you wrongthink
Re:Google’s Nest will provide data to police without a warrant by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:56AM (#32251200)
They will try but can be legally prohibited from notifying you. A server you control and have the keys to can be compelled by the police, but not without your knowledge.

Every supposed attempt to protect you is really just an attempt to justify an inherently unethical business model because it is profitable.