News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by UIUC_06 on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @08:08PM (#32245567)
The answer to "how do we fix science?" could only be some committee or bureaucracy, and that will probably work about as well as getting a bunch of HR people together to decide "how do we fix Engineering?"

The author's bio says:

José Luis Ricón is a book reviewer and blogger on various topics including longevity and a roadmap for the future of science at Nintil. You can follow him on Twitter here.

This is certainly ad hominem but is there a reason to think Mr. Ricón has any insights, experience, or publications that make him worth listening to?

Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by prichino on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @08:24PM (#32245650)
You're absolutely right.

I'd argue that to make science what it used to be, one would even have to cut funding.

Scientists used to be aristocrats interested in truth. These days they're just interested in grants.

Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by wrp on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @09:18PM (#32245969)
Ha! Just yesterday, I was talking to a colleague in the humanities about the relative pleasures of working in a field where there were practically no grants to be sought.
Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by pvaldes on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:00AM (#32247980)
> Scientists these days are just interested in grants.

Ladies and gentlemen, to add insult to injury, the greedy scientist myth strikes again.

There is not a better feeling in the world than to work for free for several years, six days a week (plus Sundays of course), with the weak promise of receiving a "turtle grant" someday. Maybe. (Tomorrow perhaps, the turtle is blocked somewhere. You will be paid in two years) and then being called "greedy".

Yes, there are people getting rich with the money for science, It just happens that they aren't the scientists. They are the politicians that keep the grants as their own personal loans. Science can't be fixed because is the guarantor of politicians that only need to go creative and put impossible requirements year after year to be allowed to keep most of the money for themselves.

In 2010 under the president Zapatero, the spanish government de-funded first and then keep for themselves the 25% of the money compromised for science. In 2015 under president Rajoy the government keep the 48% of the funds allocated for science and in 2016 the 62% of the promised money never reached any researcher. The money was used instead for, who knows... a new swimming pool for each minister maybe, or fixing accounting holes in other sectors... I wouldn't discard cocaine parties neither.

https://elpais.com/diario/2011/04/02/sociedad/1301695203_850...

https://elpais.com/elpais/2017/10/04/ciencia/1507133529_8680...

Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by prichino on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:36PM (#32403918)
Oh, I absolutely think we see things the same way. It's not greedy, they just need to pay the bills and well... Truth might suffer in that environment
Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by digitalronin on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @10:32PM (#32246324)
> Scientists used to be aristocrats interested in truth. These days they're just > interested in grants.

I'm not sure if that's actually what you're advocating, but personally I'm very much against science only being the domain of rich people who can afford to do it as a hobby.

Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by notrichmyself on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @10:50PM (#32246411)
I don't strictly disagree with that, but I do think a significant amount of science (not all) should be led by rich people. Rich people aren't random, there is a natural selection in whom becomes rich. Imperfect as that selection process is, I think it is at least better than the alternatives of popular vote or bureaucrat decision. I say this not being rich myself.

I also believe a significant amount of science should be democratically driven.

Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by marcinzm on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @10:56PM (#32246437)
>Rich people aren't random, there is a natural selection in whom becomes rich.

Generally it's the kids of rich parents.

Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by trhway on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @10:55PM (#32246433)
that reminds about the history of amateur and professional sports, including Olympics, at the end of the 19th and beginning of the 20th century - aristocrats wanted to preserve and cultivate the "pure" sports spirit and thus were pushing for amateur sports and against payments to the sportsmen, while regular people to be able to seriously play sports needed to make a living out of it.
Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by wrnr on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @08:40PM (#32245737)
People I know in academia complain about the same issues, publish or perish and all that. They even opine about formal economic models that predict that more funding/subsidies for science leads perversely to less outcome in total and not just relative to the size of the additional investment. However when you take all this as a reason to not take this industry as serious as they would like they get all offended.
Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by epgui on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @10:28PM (#32246308)
> However when you take all this as a reason to not take this industry as serious as they would like they get all offended.

Just because there exists valid criticism of a thing, does not mean all criticism of it are valid: and in my experience, I mainly roll my eyes in exasperation when people criticize science for unfair reasons.

What the public thinks is broken in science is very often not what experts think is broken in science.

Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by nonethewiser on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @10:53PM (#32246423)
> Just because there exists valid criticism of a thing, does not mean all criticism of it are valid

But in this case the valid criticism is just being fully acknowledged, rather than falsely extending the validity to all criticism.

Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by epgui on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @01:36AM (#32247203)
> in this case

In which case exactly? The comment I replied to was referring to unspecified instances.

Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by wrnr on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @11:26PM (#32246583)
How does what I say validate all or any criticism of science, I just don't think that people who work in this industry get to take all progress though human history and put that on their own lapel.

Do you know this podcast decoding the guru, it is funny at times in breaking down internet persona like Jordan Peterson and Eric Weinstein but what annoys me about it though is this "researchers" talking about fringe internet phenomena. Sure you can find your cooks on the internet but maybe they should point their sharp criticism at their own sometimes and draw conclusions from it, as in stop funding it.

What do you call people that disagree to agree on something ... a research community. For all the good science I know I can equally find you the most asinine navel gazing triviality repackaged and sold as groundbreaking progress. Please don't get me started on what experts in innovation management ISO 56002:2019 can do to help valorise all this knowledge as they piss on us from from the top floor of their ivory tower.

Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by epgui on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @01:35AM (#32247194)
> How does what I say validate all or any criticism of science

I never suggested that it did.

You sound very frustrated, my friend.

Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by wrnr on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:46AM (#32247899)
Unrelenting these people pretending to be your friend, life so futile it borders on evil.
Re:We don't know how to fix science (2021) by epgui on Friday July 29, 2022 @12:33AM (#32273179)
Sorry, what? English is my second language, and I don't know what that means.