News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla remotely converts battery pack, cutting 1/3 of range by jtbayly on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:32PM (#32243602)
I’m sorry, in what world is having an actual 90 physically installed by Tesla, and enabled physically by Tesla, able to be used and reported as such in the Tesla UI less relevant than some row in the Tesla sales db? Tesla did put in the 90 and enable it!

The fact that there isn’t a receipt proving that anybody paid for it is irrelevant. It could have been a gift, a reward, a thank you, a bribe, a reasonable business decision given the parts on hand, or an accident. Regardless, that’s on Tesla.

Am I required to ask the manufacturer if they will take back the Chrome wheels when I buy a used car just to make sure they didn’t put them on accidentally?

Re:Tesla remotely converts battery pack, cutting 1/3 of range by jabbany on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @04:51PM (#32243829)
> in what world

In our world? Based on the thread, Tesla did a battery service on a model of car with a 60 battery. Unless it was stated as upgraded, after the service it is still a 60 car to the manufacturer. A 60 car that just happened to be able to run at the performance level of a 90 version. They then state this is a bug and fixed it.

It's immoral on Tesla's side, for sure, but the previous owner selling it as an "upgraded" car without documentation is the real problem. We all know that Tesla does this market segmentation using software, so this should mean that just because the hardware's badge states something does not mean the thing will be guaranteed available.

> Am I required to ask the manufacturer if they will take back the Chrome wheels when I buy a used car just to make sure they didn’t put them on accidentally?

No, but if it turns out you mistook plastic for Chrome, it's on you (or on the seller if they misrepresented it knowingly). Just because you can't see lack of software license, doesn't mean it's there.

If you buy a laptop with a pirated copy of Windows, and later after a couple of updates the OS detects this asks for activation, do you go to Microsoft to ask them to enable your pirated software or do you go to the seller of the laptop?

Re:Tesla remotely converts battery pack, cutting 1/3 of range by thfuran on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:28PM (#32244297)
>If you buy a laptop with a pirated copy of Windows, and later after a couple of updates the OS detects this asks for activation, do you go to Microsoft to ask them to enable your pirated software or do you go to the seller of the laptop?

Except in this scenario, it wasn't pirated by the owner, it was literally installed by Microsoft

Re:Tesla remotely converts battery pack, cutting 1/3 of range by cycomanic on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:34PM (#32244368)
> > in what world

> In our world? Based on the thread, Tesla did a battery service on a model of car with a 60 battery. Unless it was stated as upgraded, after the service it is still a 60 car to the manufacturer. A 60 car that just happened to be able to run at the performance level of a 90 version. They then state this is a bug and fixed it.

It is completely irrelevant what type of car it is, they installed a 90 battery and enabled it. This is not a software licence. Are you saying it would also have been OK for Tesla at the next service to take out the battery and reinstall a 60 because they made a mistake 3 years ago? That's exactly what they did here. I also doubt that it is legal, there are implicit contracts in the warranty service and when they put in the 90 battery, you can't just renegade on those things. I have the suspicion that way too many people here have been working for too long in software, which has always been in a grey zone between purchase and licence and thus got away with things that hardware people never did.

Re:Tesla remotely converts battery pack, cutting 1/3 of range by jabbany on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @06:03PM (#32244657)
> and enabled it

Did they though...? If they did you'd think there'd be documentation of that provided as a part of the service.

The problem with this is that there is no direct comparable parallel. Physical removal is not allowed, and that most agree with. But this is not the same, there was no physical change, only a software lock. You and I would maybe like it to be treated the same, but it isn't yet.

Software licenses are revoked quite frequently. Game console vendors can blacklist serials bricking essential features of a game console, Steam blacklists stolen activation keys, storage providers can "expire" free space from promos that never included a time limit. Porting the law naively would mean all of these are not allowed either.

Re:Tesla remotely converts battery pack, cutting 1/3 of range by jtbayly on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @05:01PM (#32256917)
Did they enable it? Yes. They did. Or it wouldn't have worked. And they wouldn't have been able to disable it.
Re:Tesla remotely converts battery pack, cutting 1/3 of range by lovecg on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @05:22PM (#32244226)
Who installed the pirated copy in this hypothetical? If it was Microsoft itself for whatever reason, then yeah - it’s on them to make the customer whole.
Re:Tesla remotely converts battery pack, cutting 1/3 of range by ROTMetro on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @07:34PM (#32245379)
If I sell a base package of software, and the same codebase has advanced functionality sold as an option/upgrade, with the only difference being the software key used to activate the software, and a version of my software fails the key validation and gives you everything, am I now required to upgrade you to the full version forever?
Re:Tesla remotely converts battery pack, cutting 1/3 of range by thfuran on Tuesday July 26, 2022 @08:53PM (#32245807)
No one is suggesting that Tesla ought to be obligated to replace the battery for free whenever the new owner wants.