Re:Some Thoughts on Zig
by Schroedingersat on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:50AM
(#32251970)
> Zig is arguably in a different category and appears targeted to a more limited or lower space, in terms of general programming, which brings it more in the orbit of Rust. It's made clear that Zig's features and size will be purposely kept to the minimum, though its syntax is significantly complex. Which may hamper it, as it appears such complexity does to Rust, in terms of being picked up for general usage.
I don't understand the basis on which you're saying this. From where I'm standing only odin looks simpler, the other two just make different tradeoffs -- namely trading reduced metaprogramming facilities (and the danger of complexity that entails on user code) for more language features.
> It's hard to say how attempting to be a "better Rust" or attempts at taking on C, will work out. But, it does seem clear it's not going for more general and wide usage that languages such as Object Pascal, D, or Go cover.
D and Go are closer to rust than zig is, and object pascal is also just another OO language. Of those, only Go is even attempting to be a better C, but requiring a runtime prevents it from being a true competitor.
Zig is arguably in a different category and appears targeted to a more limited or lower space, in terms of general programming, which brings it more in the orbit of Rust. It's made clear that Zig's features and size will be purposely kept to the minimum, though its syntax is significantly complex. Which may hamper it, as it appears such complexity does to Rust, in terms of being picked up for general usage.
It's hard to say how attempting to be a "better Rust" or attempts at taking on C, will work out. But, it does seem clear it's not going for more general and wide usage that languages such as Object Pascal, D, or Go cover.
By the way, Object Pascal can be written where it comes quite close to classical Pascal, as classes are extensions of the language and more optional than required (see also advanced Records and/or Objects). Object Pascal is used in embedded systems, along with various dialects of Pascal, specific for the purpose. There are also various variants of Go, aimed directly at embedded development (TinyGo). So variants of Go and Pascal can more directly compete with Zig, and they are already well established (like Rust is). Now how this will all turn out, in say 5 years from now, anybody's guess. But, it will be an uphill climb for Zig, as for any new language trying to displace established ones.
Vlang documentation (https://github.com/vlang/v/blob/master/doc/docs.md)
Odin documentation (https://odin-lang.org/docs/overview/).
Golang by example (https://golangbyexample.com/)