Says something about how Facebook sees itself, I guess.
Leap seconds are exactly the "screwing around" you criticize.
Let's paint a picture based on actual code I've actually seen in the real world. If you ignore the leap second but keep using UTC, then in about 5 years, UTC will differ from wall clock by about 5 seconds. So if, in some software used for, I don't know maybe billing customers, someone was calculating day boundaries by doing modulo division of UTC by the number of seconds in a day (I've seen it), then in 5 years we've got a 5 second discrepancy in the number of API calls made by customer X when comparing what the software says to what the customer measured. Customers don't like this, accountants and lawyers REALLY don't like this, and us engineers will have the wonderful experience of telling them all
> "this code used to be valid until some boneheaded engineers at Facebook convinced a ton of other engineers to break the agreed upon standard about what it means to measure time in this way, and now things that used to work fine need to be patched because we've got a Y2K EVERY DAY!"
Oops, I guess ignoring wall clock time might be something other human people care about after all.
Neither do I in day to day life. But I do have to care about it when I or members of my team write code, or store and retrieve data to and from a database, or work across multiple timezones, because it can be critically important to unambiguously know whether something happened on one day or the next.
The reality is there aren't any nice, elegant solutions to this problem. Leap seconds aren't a nice solution. Meta's proposal isn't a nice solution. I don't necessarily even think it's worse than leap seconds, but it's certainly not substantially better. The key point is it's a change and one which, in my view, won't deliver enough value for everybody (beyond just Meta) to justify the level of disruption it will certainly cause if implemented.
Right back atcha.
We have three alternative time systems and a big bag of issues with each of them, but you think the extremely mundane argument that we should prefer one bag represents nauseating arrogance because you think that your favorite bag -- a different one -- is obviously correct? Come on. Do better. Be civil.
That is effectively proposing the deletion of the most commonly used time system of the three primary time systems from existence and forcing everybody and all existing systems that use it to convert to what is effectively TAI.
That is not mundane. Mundane is arguing that everybody should use TAI. Arrogant is arguing that we should force everyone to do it by redefining their dependencies under them.
Arrogant is imposing a big nuisance on everyone every year or two. It is not arrogant to ask for a nuisance affecting millions to be dropped.
If there was a scheme that fixed only the wrong usages, that would be fine. But, it is frankly absurd that we should even consider breaking carefully designed programs correctly using their dependencies to fix programs incorrectly using their dependencies especially when it is trivial for the wrong usages to be fixed manually.
Not announcing any more leap seconds will break exactly nothing.
People using the wrong dependency should fix their system to use the right dependency. They should not campaign to steal the name and replace it, that is absurd.
The only people who care or need to do not use UTC. They use TAI, and a separate continuous log of fractional seconds.
UTC has one role, and that is Standard worldwide civil time. Telling people who need Standard civil time to use TAI makes everything strictly worse: not only do you then not match most of the world, but you still have to track irregular, unpredictable corrections to be able to sync with everybody else.
That is what is proposed to be fixed and that you are arguing against for reasons you don't know or, apparently, care about.
Switching civil time to TAI would break everything, most of which cannot be fixed. Random breakage is the problem. More breakage would be strictly worse.
That's just... completely incorrect and totally false? Have you ever even worked for a business? Have you ever read how time libraries are actually written?
Please, go read the Python `datetime` library: https://github.com/python/cpython/blob/0fe645d6fd22a6f57e777... which is used to calculate a UTC timestamp: https://github.com/python/cpython/blob/0fe645d6fd22a6f57e777...
It is literally built on the exact assumption that 0 means January 1, 1970 and that right now is (number of seconds in a day) x (number of days since Jan 1 1970). If we stop adjusting UTC, then by this time next year UTC will be one second out of date with our wall-clock times, and calling `datetime.now().isoformat()` will give us a timestamp that's 1 second off from the wall-time of a user. At one-second past midnight on the 20th of the month, your computer will incorrectly be spitting out timestamps saying it's exactly midnight of the 19th. That's what you might call a major breaking change.
Big Tech companies/Anti Big Tech lobbyists massively oversimplify in their pitch to influential people to deregulate/overregulate certain areas. In both cases they end up making poor decisions for the general case both end up making the average case worse for everyone except themselves. It's about creating a market where none need exist. Facebook doesn't need to care about time really. It's not remotely important to their business.
I've built and worked on platforms with sub microsecond measuring requirements and this stuff didn't bother me. This is idle bad money finding work for itself at the expense of everyone else.
Disclosure: I am/was an early investor in facebook in 2012. Mark is turning it all to dirt because he's run out of ideas
I agree, but I'm also - sad to say - less than surprised to find engineers at a Big Tech firm taking a high-handed, not to mention narrow and ill-informed, approach over the issue and trying to impose their will on a global scale. My worry here is that, Meta being Meta, they carry quite a lot of influence and may actually gain some traction.
EDIT: I'll add a bit more colour here. At the core of our platform we manage a database containing billions of legacy timestamped records (or events, if you prefer), adding more and more every day. Without even giving it a great deal of thought I guarantee you that this proposal will cause us more problems that it solves and will distract us from making more valuable investments of time and effort that would benefit our business should it be implemented. Sure, we can no doubt fix all these problems, but we've got better things to do. I imagine that many other businesses would be similarly affected and would take a similar view.
I wholeheartedly oppose it.