News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Remember the "borderless" Internet? It's officially dead by ChuckMcM on Thursday November 10, 2011 @01:00PM (#3221048)
One can hope that our judiciary would toss out the more egregious parts of this effort at censorship and control as they did with the CDA. However, given that the Internet is seen as the proximate cause of governmental overthrow in some places I suspect fear will over come common sense.
Re:Remember the "borderless" Internet? It's officially dead by marshray on Thursday November 10, 2011 @02:19PM (#3221381)
But in Egypt, the shutting down of the internet was an even more proximate cause.

The US is not like China where this massive firewall infrastructure is practical for two simple reasons.

1. There are people who will compromise for the sake of protecting children or "property", but just about any voter will laugh at the idea of a government-run morality enforcement service. Particularly given the cost involved.

2. Other censorship-minded countries seem to be able to concentrate their resources on border firewalls to keep the inharmonious concepts out. This requires a big infrastructure even in a little place like Iran or Syria.

But the US has a healthy mix of users and controversial servers. Any given router may have users and websites on either side. There simply isn't enough rack space in the world to do deep inspection and blocking at every node. Instead you'd end up with prohibition-era like raids on some small random sample of servers and users. That would be simultaneously one of the most expensive and unpopular government projects ever.

My guess is the DoJ is going to stick to "takedowns" of small video streaming and fake handbag sites for a while yet.

Re:Remember the "borderless" Internet? It's officially dead by gbog on Thursday November 10, 2011 @03:00PM (#3221593)
It would be ironical for USA government to ask for Chinese expertise.
Re:Remember the "borderless" Internet? It's officially dead by jwhitlark on Thursday November 10, 2011 @04:14PM (#3221901)
The don't need to. Most of the expertise came from multi-national corporations, who would be happy to help out.
Re:Remember the "borderless" Internet? It's officially dead by pnathan on Thursday November 10, 2011 @05:06PM (#3222114)
Well, I believe the top censorship software is American. Websense in particular.