News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by spiznnx on Thursday July 21, 2022 @02:46PM (#32183200)
I'm trans and I'd generally like more follow up studies to determine if various medically-important sex-dimorphic factors are downstream of endocrine differences. Otherwise I won't know which profile fits me better and I might get worse medical outcomes.

Personally, I much prefer to learn about sex dimorphism in analytical/academic contexts, rather than in emotional/social ones. I actively seek out and read papers like this in my free time.

Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by jauer on Thursday July 21, 2022 @02:39PM (#32183117)
I mean, the first step is actually determining what the sex-specific mechanism is.

Microbes in your gut generally aren't checking sex chromosomes. They interact with sex hormones (see Rizzetto et al., 2018 cited in the paper for this very thing) which often reflect sex chromosomes. Hormone levels or response may not match what is typical of sex chromosomes for a number of reasons including: 46XY women (androgen insensitivity), trans people on HRT, women post-menopause, and sometimes cancer treatment.

IMO it would be less alienating and lead to better health outcomes for everyone if we talked more about testosterone-dominant or estrogen-dominant endocrine systems (or other systems as appropriate).

Also whether dimorphic effects are a result of a one-shot process (e.g. grow testes or ovaries, grow breasts), or a recurring process (hormone levels triggering lactation, sweat patterns).

Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by causi on Thursday July 21, 2022 @02:16PM (#32182790)
If it's a subject that makes you uncomfortable then don't read about it. I wouldn't expect people discussing human sexual dimorphism to alter their discussion to accommodate gender dysphoria any more than I'd expect entomologists to alter their discussion about spiders to accommodate my arachnophobia. You do raise the question of whether the potential effects of the hormone alterations attending gender transition on the gut microbiome have been studied. I'd be curious about those results.
Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by belorn on Thursday July 21, 2022 @02:41PM (#32183142)
People have done studies on sex-differences on trans people and the results is quite interesting (https://health.clevelandclinic.org/research-on-the-transgend...).

Basically, transgender brain has some sex-differences that resembles the gender that the person identifies as, and that is before hormone therapies has been applied. If they did such study on antibiotics then you would likely have to do multiple ones, including if the person have taken hormones before or after puberty.

Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by zamberzand on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:38PM (#32185467)
Trans woman here, here are my thoughts:

So, research into the impact of biological sex on medication, and similar, doesn't really seem alienating to me. Despite the existence of trans people, there are obviously two main categories that people fall into in a medical sense.

That said, I do think it would be a mistake to assume that the conclusions of any research into biological sex can be directly extrapolated to trans people. If we know that the relevant mechanism is hormones or chromosomes we may be able to predict effects on trans people--but we also might not be able to, if the mechanism isn't known, or for whatever other reason.

One well known example is that trans women's risk of breast cancer is more comparable to cis women than cis men. If I recall correctly, this is because the relevant factors are basically whether a person has breasts or not, and of course, trans women grow breasts when on estrogen.

Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by nikkwong on Thursday July 21, 2022 @02:16PM (#32182778)
The differences in treatment effect are in relation to the recipient's biological sex, so it's unnecessary to take gender preference into account.
Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by connicpu on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:28PM (#32183762)
Unfortunately "biological sex" becomes extremely nebulous when you take into account years of cross-sex hormone treatment. Many of the genes that control sexually dimorphic traits are activated by sex hormones. Someone who's been taking exogenous hormones for years will have a very different medical profile than someone who has not.
Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by smegsicle on Thursday July 21, 2022 @02:42PM (#32183156)
is there any case where it does make sense to take gender "preference" into account? besides pronouns?

seems to me that those who insist that gender and sex are distinct also heavily imply that biological sex is mostly meaningless, so its unclear what they actually expect anyone to care about

Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by dragonwriter on Thursday July 21, 2022 @02:53PM (#32183294)
> seems to me that those who insist that gender and sex are distinct also heavily imply that biological sex is mostly meaningless

Gender (either socially ascribed or gender identity, though those two can differ from each other) and biological sex are objectively different things.

Most people who value gender identity rather than the particular indicia of biological sex other people prefer as a basis of socially ascribed gender generally view biological sex as a multidimensional space which includes (among other things, some of which are mutable) gender identity, not a simple binary (even if the distribution may be strongly bimodal.)

> its unclear what they actually expect anyone to care about

Generally, gender identity rather than other factors to the extent that society divides people up by ascribed genders. But also generally a lot less gender segregation, and especially strict binary gender segregation, at all, and when distinctions need to be made to which particular sex- and/or gender-stereotyped traits are relevant, to make distinctions on the particular relevant trait rather than by stereotypical association.

Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by Latty on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:00PM (#32184192)
> also heavily imply that biological sex is mostly meaningless

This is a puzzling statement to me. The whole concept of being trans requires that there is a distinction between gender identity and biological sex. If the latter didn't matter at all, being trans wouldn't exist. If anything, trans people would surely be the most aware of biological sex and it's impact on them, as they are not happy with it?

To me, it's like saying an adoptive parent is trying to imply biological parenthood is meaningless. Surely those who wished to have biological children but could not and adopt instead are often the people most sharply aware of it?

Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by matthewmacleod on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:11PM (#32184352)
Not trans myself, but I can tell you from my personal experience that very few people are actually uncomfortable or alienated by topics like this – that's usually more of a bit of fiction belonging to the "you can't even say WOMAN any more" genre.

In contrast, trans people are usually extremely aware of their biology and related medical requirements - to a greater extent than many others. Like any other topic that might be sensitive, the best approach is to be respectful, accurate, and specific. For example, don't do the thing up-thread of banging on about how "gender isn't relevant to this conversation" without really having that insight.

Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by fourseventy on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:29PM (#32183774)
If people feel uncomfortable or alienated by the truth that is their problem.
Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by Latty on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:05PM (#32184251)
Adopted parents/children often feel uncomfortable being reminded of the "truth" of their biological parenthood. While we should absolutely focus on being accepting and treating adoption as just as valid as biological parenthood (because it is, just as with gender identity), it would also be cruel and unreasonable to intentionally go our of your way to point out someone's lack of a biological relationship with their parents when there was no need for it and you know it causes them to be upset.

Largely, this is a problem with society for telling them they are lesser for that, and people having treated them badly because of that, which they have then internalised as shame or a feeling of being less than.

Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by daenz on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:17PM (#32184433)
>Largely, this is a problem with society

In the adoption example, I would argue that it is not a product of society, but just very present in society. I don't have data to back this up, but kids seem to be innately cruel about things like a peer being adopted, and I don't think it was programmed into them from society.

Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by Latty on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:19PM (#32184458)
If there is an innate cruelty in our children that we allow to fester and allow them to apply in our society, rather than teaching them against it, then that is absolutely a product and failing of it.

We are pretty advanced, we can do more than throw our hands up in the air and say "that's how it is" when faced with problems. If we choose not to, it is exactly that: a choice.

Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by daenz on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:37PM (#32184680)
I'm not throwing up my hands (if you were suggesting that) because I still think kids should be socialized. I would agree that society should socialize it out of them, and if they don't, it is a failing of society, but I still don't agree it is a product, because product implies origin. It's more interesting to me to understand why the origin exists.
Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by vanattab on Thursday July 21, 2022 @06:17PM (#32185891)
It's nothing special about being adopted, kids can be brutal about anything unique/rare difference an individual has from the group. (Only transkid bullied, only poor kid bullied, only redhead bullied, say you like country when everyone else say rap or vis versa, etc) kids can be brutal and irrational in groups for sure. And if you follow politics you notice adults aren't much better ether.
Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by sn0w_crash on Thursday July 21, 2022 @02:29PM (#32182975)
I understand why you are saying this, but one should not be made uncomfortable by reality. That may be the case for some, but it is easier to change mindset than it is to alter reality.
Re:Antibiotics have sex-specific effects on the gut microbio... by locopati on Thursday July 21, 2022 @02:44PM (#32183186)
Root causes here probably aren't about chromosomes but about hormone levels so something else that is more about amount of N. That's how you look at things without making it about "male" 9r "female" (since, to use hormones as an example, those vary between individuals and within an individual over a life).