News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Politically Incorrect: Spec Work by _delirium on Wednesday November 09, 2011 @06:58PM (#3218154)
It's interesting how much more positive the reaction overall is to spec-work not in design, like Kaggle's machine-learning competitions. There's some negative sentiment towards Kaggle, but much less, and much of it boils down to, "meh, I don't consider it worth my time, but if others do, that's their decision". I'm guessing it's mostly a question of economics; ML consultants don't feel like spec work threatens to seriously affect their pay, while designers are more worried. Photographers seem to be at the far end, with photography forums full of all sorts of crazed ranting, some even claiming that people who CC-license photos and upload them to Wikimedia Commons are unethical.
Re:Politically Incorrect: Spec Work by tptacek on Wednesday November 09, 2011 @09:18PM (#3218559)
Spec work is normal in consulting and law.

The anti-spec crusade is unique to graphic design.

Obviously, in every field, lots of practitioners will refuse to do work on spec! But only in graphic design is there a marketing effort to depict the practice as unethical.

Re:Politically Incorrect: Spec Work by itsnotvalid on Wednesday November 09, 2011 @07:33PM (#3218247)
For Kaggle there is always money given out. In the design world, the could be cases that simply money are not given out.

For machine learning, you have some quantitative metrics for performance measurement, whereas there is no measurement of such in creative areas.