Re:Half of Americans anticipate a U.S. civil war soon
by weeblewobble on Thursday July 21, 2022 @01:47AM
(#32176183)
Not trying to be glib but this literally already happened. The Southern states seceded (with a very similar mindset to those who want to secede today) and the federal government physically dominated them with guns.
Obviously a lot has changed since 1861 but it seems odd to act like it's totally inconceivable
Re:Half of Americans anticipate a U.S. civil war soon
by Supermancho on Thursday July 21, 2022 @10:02AM
(#32179516)
> The Southern states seceded (with a very similar mindset to those who want to secede today)
The incentive and reasoning is a lot weaker than in the 1800s, so I wouldn't say similar. Now it's more of a nostalgic fantasy and it's known that the sentiment endures.
> Obviously a lot has changed since 1861
That's the point.
You can't aim a gun at someone to changing their beliefs, much less kill your way toward that goal. What you will do is create more and more costly asynchronous warfare, as we have seen with people in other nations that our military has tried to subdue (ie Hearts and Minds). Modern communication has created and maintained rebel organizations over great distances with little investment and minimal effort. What's worse is modern warfare usually empowers the targets of that military effort. eg Running some tanks over to Texas is basically agreeing to destroy those tanks when they are inevitably captured or left behind, because it's too vulnerable and expensive to bring them back from the front lines (which would be everywhere), as the Russians have learned.