News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DALL·E now available in beta by tptacek on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:59PM (#32169723)
Your input isn't being polluted by this any more than it is when the tokens in it are ground up into vectors and transformed mathematically. You just have an easier time understanding this transformation.
Re:DALL·E now available in beta by throwuxiytayq on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:46PM (#32170388)
Obviously, it's polluted. Undisputably. In a mathematical sense, an extra (black box) transformation is performed on the input to the model. In a practical sense (eg. if you're researching the model), this is like having dirty laboratory tools - all measurements are slightly off. The presumption by OpenAI is that the measurements are off in the correct way.

I'm interested in using Dall-E commercially, but I think some competitor offering sampling with raw input will have a better chance at my wallet.

Re:DALL·E now available in beta by tptacek on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @03:13PM (#32170748)
It's a fucking AI picture generator. The whole thing is a series of (literally) inscrutable black boxes. This is not a good argument.
Re:DALL·E now available in beta by throwuxiytayq on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @03:34PM (#32171019)
Yeah man, but literally the entire point of this AI picture generator is that it's, like, super accurate at rendering the prompt, and stuff.

I don't understand the relevance of the black box's scrutability - I just want to play with the black box. I am interested in increasing my understanding of the black box, not of a trust-me-it's-great-our-intern-steve-made-it black box derivative.

Re:DALL·E now available in beta by tptacek on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @03:39PM (#32171085)
You should make your own black boxes then. By all means, send your dollars to whatever service passes your purity test; I'm just saying that the idea that DALL-E is "polluting" your input is risible. It's already polluting your data at, like, a subatomic level, at dimensionalities it hadn't even occurred to you to consider, and at enormous scale.
Re:DALL·E now available in beta by tablespoon on Thursday July 21, 2022 @09:48AM (#32179352)
> Your input isn't being polluted by this any more than it is when the tokens in it are ground up into vectors and transformed mathematically. You just have an easier time understanding this transformation.

These kinds of modifications are obviously different. At least the mathematical transformations are attempting at least some level of fidelity to user input, these ones aren't (e.g. someone mentioned they're sometimes getting androgynous results and speculates the added terms are conflicting with the ones they provided in their input). Not all black boxes are equivalent.