Re:Do Infinite Pencils Exist?
by 9TRHEsEdDwZAySX on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @01:47PM
(#32155353)
This is a controversial topic within mathematics.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophy_of_mathematics#Math...
Re:Do Infinite Pencils Exist?
by jimhefferon on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @02:17PM
(#32155801)
> controversial topic within mathematics
Yes, you are certainly right, within the group of people who think about the philosophy of math. But that is what makes OP's:
> When a mathematician says infinity they mean a repeatable process that we can keep doing forever.
obviously false. Some philosophically-minded mathematicians may well agree with that, but certainly not all. And as for the "average" professional mathematician who never thinks about that stuff, they would not at all agree with OP.
Numbers are concepts, not concrete things. In the same way that authors of autobiographies are not literally held within the pages of the books they write about themselves, the numerals you write on a page are a representation of the actual thing, not the thing itself.