Re:Grove.io: Hosted, Searchable IRC Chat For Teams
by leahculver on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @07:04PM
(#3213524)
I think it's actually an issue of perception. When I hear Jabber or XMPP, I think of one-to-one chat and when I hear IRC I definitely think of group chat. In general, IRC clients seem more tailored towards groups.
That said, there's definitely room for both protocols and I could see supporting XMPP as well at some point.
Re:Grove.io: Hosted, Searchable IRC Chat For Teams
by tilgovi on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @08:17PM
(#3213771)
XMPP MUC is not fun, nor fun to scale. IRC has netsplits, but it does work reliably for tons of people all day every day.
Re:Grove.io: Hosted, Searchable IRC Chat For Teams
by mweibel on Wednesday November 09, 2011 @02:53AM
(#3214705)
I don't really think that's true. Look at Jabber.org which is probably the biggest jabber network out there and it seems they're scaling pretty well.
Edit: Also XMPP supports UTF-8 for everyhting out of the box and as far as I know it's not really possible with IRC (or did that change over the last years?). E.g. nicks with non-ascii chars are no problem to have..
Why do you think it's not fun?
Re:Grove.io: Hosted, Searchable IRC Chat For Teams
by gwillen on Tuesday November 08, 2011 @09:44PM
(#3213993)
XMPP MUC also has the problem that the largest XMPP client, Google Talk in Gmail, afaik does not support it. It handles multi-user chats via some proprietary method that only works for Gtalk clients.
At any rate, my original comment came off a bit the wrong way. I'm not trying to say that IRC isn't a workable solution for this kind of group chat system, as it clearly is. I just don't see why using IRC over Jabber (which seems more technically suited to this domain) is a selling point, especially in a marketplace crowded with group chat solutions.