News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by Lio on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:24AM (#32092683)
This again.

They’re not giving you the heating hardware for free.

They’re selling you the heated seats and then selling you the ability to turn them on separately.

Not to mention the arbitrage opportunities. BMW are now the only car dealer network that can trade cars back without features and then add them in for no cost before they go back out on sale.

...or turn them off and get used car buyer to pay for them yet again.

Rent seeking MBA fuckers.

The only hope is that the market punishes them. The problem is that if every company does this then they act as a cartel and stop the market working correctly.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by Biologist123 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:49AM (#32092806)
> Rent seeking MBA fuckers.

T-shirt slogan.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by tchock23 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:20AM (#32092992)
Or a new Radiohead lyric
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by TAForObvReasons on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:52AM (#32092823)
Tesla discussed doing this last year: https://driveteslacanada.ca/model-3/tesla-unlock-model-3-hea...

They had paid range upgrade in 2016: https://electrek.co/2016/11/08/tesla-in-car-purchase-softwar...

Yet it seems the market gave Tesla a pass?

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by gruturo on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:55AM (#32093651)
The price of a 60KWh Model S was substantially lower than the price of a 75KWh one, and Tesla had economies of scale by just building 75KWh packs and using them everywhere.

It was not an unreasonable value proposition for the end user, but most importantly it was a single one-off payment. It's the monthly cost which really annoys me in the BMW case. Literally rent seeking. There is no justification whatsoever for a monthly fee for a heated seat, there is no back-end to run and maintain (other than what they build explicitly to make the rent a possibility, and fuck that).

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by betwixthewires on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:49AM (#32092807)
BMW isn't the only company doing this, Tesla actually began all this by building one hardware platform for manufacturing simplicity and then locking the functionality behind software paywalls. Several other car companies have since done things like this with their entertainment units, remote start and the like.

It should be illegal. This is all just a new workaround to consumer protections by way of EULAs, if I buy the hardware there should be a lawful way for me to use it. If a product is pure software, fine, but if it's hardware I bought and it won't work without some specific software the manufacturer should enable me to use it with my own software.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by dash2 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @02:54AM (#32092834)
> It should be illegal. This is all just a new workaround to consumer protections by way of EULAs, if I buy the hardware there should be a lawful way for me to use it.

OK, I'll bite. Why? This is a free transaction between two parties, why should it be banned?

(There are several possible answers, I'm just interested which one motivates your comment.)

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by betwixthewires on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:05AM (#32092909)
So, when we talk naively about free markets we commonly ignore the Firm. In industries you have the propensity for cartels to form, or for "industry standards" to come to exist that enable actors to work against the interest of their consumers.

You also get economies of scale that lead to capital concentration, razor thin margins and extreme efficiency reliant on capital intensive business models. As a result you wind up with massive barriers to entry for new competitors, and so the usual "someone will come along and outcompete" doesn't really work. It works when you're selling doodads and fruit, but semiconductors and car manufacturing aren't fruit.

In particular, industries that become foundational to the workings of a society become impossible to avoid engaging in. In the US, cars are a given, you have to have a car. One car company does something and gets away with it with their customers, so the rest follow suit and now you're in an environment where everyone does it and there's no way out. There's no direct collusion here, just neither has an interest in competing on a front because the the practice benefits them both.

This is where industry regulation comes in. It comes in only when it isn't an entirely free transaction between two parties. Where a party must use a product or service, or where competitors collude directly or indirectly, state action is warranted. Examples where the party must use a product would be cars, food and car insurance. Direct collusion is interactive, indirect is passive, such as an entire industry without direct cooperation engaging in practices like this.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by dash2 on Friday July 15, 2022 @06:02AM (#32106496)
I don't think the cartel answer is a good one. The standard problem with cartels is that prices are too high. There seems no reason why this would be more or less of a problem with the approach of renting services.

Also, the claim that the car market is uncompetitive is not so easy to make. The top 5 players have about half of the market.[1] This is less concentrated than (say) the market for breakfast cereal. The market is quite global. Artificial barriers to entry have not stopped numerous recent entrants. It might even be that new pricing strategies like selling services will allow more entrants to the market - Tesla being the obvious example.

[1] https://courses.lumenlearning.com/suny-microeconomics/chapte... - probably not the best source but ok for a quickie.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by amardeep on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:18AM (#32093414)
It reminds me of inkjet printers and the issue with ink cartridges. Free market doesn't always result in an equilibrium which is not consumer hostile.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by TedDoesntTalk on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:14AM (#32093387)
I suppose it can work to the benefit of consumers, too… sometimes. Remember when the cell service providers all charged per text message? And had plans with “minutes”?
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by rpadovani on Thursday July 14, 2022 @05:37AM (#32093868)
Cries in German.

In Italy, prices started going down for mobile only when, back in 2007, they introduced a law to make unlawful minimum duration of contracts.

After that, given users could switch each month, prices went really down 'cause there was a _real_ market.

Here in Germany, you are locked to an operator for 24 months, and prices are crazy high. So, yes, please, more regulations.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by YeBanKo on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:18AM (#32093415)
Ok, I will bite too. The transaction is not free.

First, there is a huge asymmetry in the relationship between a consumer and such a large entity as a car maker.

Second, you can’t vote with your feet much, as the market is controlled by a very limited number players who can easily collude to manipulate the market without explicitly doing so.

Third, many if not all car manufacturers receive subsidies from the government in various forms. Tesla as an example, selling regulatory credits plus consumer tax credit and rebates. If it is subsidized by tax payers, then why not attach strings to it prohibiting anti consumer behavior.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by patrickk on Thursday July 14, 2022 @05:25AM (#32093800)
> Second, you can’t vote with your feet much, as the market is controlled by a very limited number players who can easily collude to manipulate the market without explicitly doing so.

Well said. There are a handful of entities which control all the major car brands. It's the illusion of choice.

https://www.whichcar.com.au/car-advice/car-manufacturer-bran...

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by grapeskin on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:40AM (#32093560)
Imagine this.

You buy a fan for $20. It works. It has a low, medium, and high setting.

One of the most influential fan makers decides they want to make a new product. It’s fan 2.0. It’s $21 dollars and has a $1 a month fee to unlock high speed. The package says “optional settings for a monthly fee. Buy only what you need and save.”

Other fan makers realize this is a great way to make money. 2 years later, all fans have this option.

Influential fan corp puts a press release for their revolutionary new product that’ll change the world. Fan 3.0. Medium speed is $3 a month.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by this_was_posted on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:03AM (#32092895)
For me it's because ownership should mean true ownership, just like how you should be allowed to repair your own devices if you want.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by mavhc on Thursday July 14, 2022 @05:49AM (#32093949)
Don't buy a closed source car
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by selfhoster11 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @06:36AM (#32094191)
Great. Point me to the next closest open source/hardware car that's not a jalopy, is road-worthy and crash-safe, is globally available, and that doesn't cost 2x the retail price of a "consumer" car.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by mavhc on Thursday July 14, 2022 @11:01AM (#32096891)
How many closed source cars are approved for every country on Earth?
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by selfhoster11 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @12:26PM (#32098125)
The point isn't that a particular closed source car is available, but that there are always a few locally-available models that do the basic things well no matter where you are in the world. With open source cars, this is unlikely.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by mavhc on Friday July 15, 2022 @07:08AM (#32106907)
No one said it would be easy, but offering a software suite to a hardware company shouldn't be too hard of a sell. Not like any of them really want to make software.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by Schroedingersat on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:43AM (#32093580)
Because 'you must buy a product from one of 10 companies that frequently collude in order to participate in society because we systematically dismantled all other options for transport' is not a free transaction>

Second reason: even if it were, 'free transaction' is not a measure of good. We ban carcinogens in food, lawn darts, and all sorts of other things because sometimes collective decisions for the common good are better for people than allowing society to be atomised and taken advantage of. This is the entire premise behind laws in the first place.

Thirdly, if there are ongoing conditions for the use of something after it is sold, laws preventing certain modifications by the buyer, and/or secrets required for its ongoing use/editing of software that are not cha7ngeable or knowable by the buywr, then the product was not 'sold' and representing the $50k paid as anything other than rent is, in any sane society, fraud.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by Ygg2 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:57AM (#32093264)
A free transaction between parties is a horribly abstract term.

I mean a gunman robbing you on a side of the road is a free transaction between two free parties. Gunman is free to shoot you, and you are free to run away or take the bullet.

Free transaction between peers is what is actually useful considering.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by mike_hock on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:23AM (#32093455)
It shouldn't. But it most certainly also shouldn't be illegal for me to then go and hack the hardware that I own to do what I want.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by asiachick on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:10AM (#32093356)
Tesla wasn't the first. I don't know who was but I know the differences in many printers are software only. The differences in many GPUs (Nvidia Quadro vs non-Quadro) are just drivers.

I don't know where to draw the line. I hated that Tesla has a (pay $2k for a software upgrade for acceleration). Imagine it will escalate. Pay $1k to get your air-conditioner to 60f otherwise it stops at 68f. Pay $3k to turn 15 degrees sharper. Pay $1.5k for your defrosters to work twice as fast.

On the other hand, my phones, computers, and game machines, all came with no software and I pay for apps and Apple in particular has made it popular to pay for individual features inside an app. Download a photo editing app and it will be $2 for the blur feature, $2 for the tilt-shift feature, or $10 for all features... though now it's escalated to $XX per year on most iOS apps that have top end features.

I don't know how to feel about it. I used to pay ~$50 a year for photoshop (upgrading every other version for $200). Now I pay $120 a year. I mean, I like the idea of paying once but the truth is, for software I actually used, I'd pay for upgrades, even if only to get the software working on the latest OS version.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by raverbashing on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:26AM (#32093470)
> The differences in many GPUs (Nvidia Quadro vs non-Quadro) are just drivers.

Are they? I mean, the GPU might be the same, and it might run with Quadro drivers, but the board might be different (cooling, power management, etc)

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by helsinkiandrew on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:25AM (#32093020)
I wonder how long before CAN bus dongles that unlock 'locked' functionality appear for sale.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by semi-extrinsic on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:50AM (#32093624)
Oh, we've been there for decades. My old 2001 Peugeot 307 was sold without the "driving computer" - the function where you could click a button and cycle through fuel consumption/range/speed on the small display.

It was a popular mod to retrofit the appropriate button (the wires were still there) and to have someone with access to Peugeot Planet activate the driving computer feature.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by sligor on Thursday July 14, 2022 @05:42AM (#32093901)
I wonder how long before car companies convince law makers that "unlocking heated seat" impacts critical safety of the car and voids insurance in case of accident.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by HyprMusic on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:47AM (#32093609)
You can already unlock spec features (called VO codes) in BMWs with a $20 dongle, some pirated dealer software and a simple YouTube video. Maybe they will introduce stronger protections but enabling features you didn't spec in a BMW is already a very common and easy thing to do. The only difference is now you don't need to scavenge the hardware from a breaker's yard.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by HyprMusic on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:41AM (#32093564)
The heated seat hardware isn't expensive, the blocks can be bought for about $15/chair second hand on their e90 range. I highly doubt it costs BMW any more than a couple of months of the rental cost and I strongly suspect over the life of a car they will get at least a couple of months rent and justify the cost.

I, for one, welcome this change. BMW makes retrofit kits for everything because they know people want features that aren't in their spec and they're very expensive. I buy old, second hand cars and I'm at the mercy of the original buyer when it comes to features included. This way, not only do I get the option of a feature that was never bought, but I can enable it only for the couple of months I'd actually need it. Or better yet, I'll do what I do with everything I own and hack it, unlocking everything I can.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by Tildey on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:45AM (#32093597)
Bold of you to assume they will still have the working cloud infrastructure for you to enable that in 20 years
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by HyprMusic on Thursday July 14, 2022 @05:02AM (#32093683)
That's not how it currently works. The car's spec is stored on a central database and set in the specific modules when the car is first produced. You only lose the customised VO codes when you update a module (not a common thing to do, even for car modders) but even then you can often convince a dealer to add your retrofit's VO code to the central database. I strongly suspect that the subscription will piggy-back off of this infrastructure and the subscription will set/unset the VO codes.

BMW are fantastic with parts and supporting older car maintenance. Even now I can order 20 year old parts (including electronic modules) new from BMW.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by rlpb on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:58AM (#32093663)
> Or better yet, I'll do what I do with everything I own and hack it, unlocking everything I can.

The problem comes when the manufacturer starts demanding legal "protection" against people hacking their own possessions, or sharing technical information about their possessions.

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by HyprMusic on Thursday July 14, 2022 @05:09AM (#32093725)
It already exists. All their part documentation, all the dealer software, software to unlock ECUs, remove engine restrictions to get an additional 50bhp, Android apps to unlock features.. it's all widely available on dedicated websites and they've done nothing to stop it. The only thing they have ever stopped being shared is their TIS manuals which are incredibly expensive service manuals that they sell to dealers. But even in that case, they agreed to look the other way as long as the providers of the TIS manuals only let them be accessed by existing users.

BMW have bundled features you can't access for a long term, and modders have been enabling them for a long time. Just look up the 328i to 330i tuning software for an example, you can use free software (bimmerlabs.com) to derestrict your engine to same power as the next model (it's the same engine, just restricted).

Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by Nullabillity on Thursday July 14, 2022 @06:47AM (#32094270)
If it's cheap enough to always include then it's cheap enough to always turn on.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by dzhiurgis on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:59AM (#32093287)
Given how much regulation is out there to make car road-legal... It's barely open market.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by travbrack on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:26AM (#32093031)
Is it rent seeking when people have a choice? There are plenty of car brands that don't do this garbage.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by Ygg2 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @03:49AM (#32093214)
I'm pretty sure the other manufacturer are just waiting to see how this pans out before adding their own spin.
Re:BMW introduces new heated seat subscription in UK by stu432 on Thursday July 14, 2022 @04:41AM (#32093565)
I'm pretty sure the end state here is that you just have a car-as-a-service. Now you can use the same car for someone who wants premium as someone who wants basic. After all, you will own nothing and be happy.