With respect, this is complete nonsense. It would only be true if there were no replacement for Elop who could not produce similar returns for a lower cost.
Supply and demand, not intrinsic value.
I realize Elop's pay is set by supply and demand, and if Nokia could find a cheaper person with the same qualities, they would and should hire him.
I'm just pointing out that it is in Nokia's best interest to pay significant amounts of cash comp to a good executive even if that executive "runs the company into the ground".
With many millions of dollars of shareholder wealth at stake, only people with a strong track record should be seriously considered.
Sure there are problems with corporate governance but ultimately we're talking about the risk of misallocating capital belonging to investors, whose job it is to oversee the allocation.
Sooo, it's the job of the board of directors to select who the CEO (an officer in Corporate Law-speak) is.
Personally I think there's a lot of freeloading off the small group of big players that do exercise control. I have a certain amount of faith that they won't vote in a way that's seriously adverse to my interests as a little fish.
(Yes, I'm ignoring the time value of money, risk, etc, to simplify.)
The best you could ever hope to do is "CEO candidates with this kind of background tend to have this kind of record when taking over this kind of company", which I'm sure is quite an illuminating sample.
I really don't get the point you are making. Are you telling me that a struggling company shouldn't try to get what they believe is the best possible CEO, provided his pay package is vastly smaller than the variance in possible outcomes for the company?
You realize that with the narrow exception of a few quant traders, you've pretty much described all business decisions.
The question is why the shareholders put up with it, and I don't have an answer to that question.
I guess many should be sorta happy since it allows untried upstarts to disrupt the market and truly well run companies to expand. I feel sorry for all the people caught up in the fail.
Suppose Nokia's chances of survival were 10% without Stephen Elop and 20% with him. That means he is worth 0.1 x value of Nokia if Nokia survives.
If you pay Elop based directly on the performance of Nokia (i.e., he only gets paid if Nokia does well), he'll stay at Microsoft. Why leave MS for an 80% chance of getting paid nothing? Obviously Elop demands some cash up front, a golden parachute, or something of that nature, and a rational board of directors will give it to him.
In 80% of situations like this, the CEO gets paid well for running the company into the ground. But that's a better situation than the alternative, i.e. 90% of similarly situated companies crashing and burning.