News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why isn't GWT or Vaadin more popular among Java d... by mike_hearn on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:18PM (#32072133)
The language you write an UI in, isn't directly connected to how it feels. There are plenty of old feeling web, native and mobile apps out there.

Some years ago I wrote a desktop app in JavaFX. This is a Java UI toolkit (though I wrote in Kotlin), but, you can style it with CSS. It was a piece of cake to give it a GitHub-ish feel. The result felt a lot like a web app, just without the browser chrome. The app in question was a peer to peer app that benefited from some libraries written in Java, so it was a good fit for what the app needed to do.

At the moment it's a bit painful to do this sort of thing because of a lack of good distribution tools. But, that's about to change ...

Re:Ask HN: Why isn't GWT or Vaadin more popular among Java d... by oneplane on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @12:56PM (#32072728)
JavaFX was about to be revolutionary for over a decade ;-) First it was availability, then it was integration, then it was build tooling and now it's distribution.

Most of the Java-for-the-user only exists on Android and niche markets (like some financial software).

And while it's true that the language doesn't determine the UX, the different things I mentioned (frameworks, languages etc.) are mostly relevant due to the mindshare, adoption and general availability of up-to-date resources to get the job done.

Re:Ask HN: Why isn't GWT or Vaadin more popular among Java d... by mike_hearn on Wednesday July 13, 2022 @06:47AM (#32080946)
I don't think JavaFX is revolutionary, it's just a nicely designed UI toolkit. There are lots of markets where software needs GUIs but doesn't actually benefit from anything the web provides, beyond the general inertia you mention.