News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Responsible stewardship of the UEFI Secure Boot ecosystem by ziml77 on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @07:13AM (#32068217)
You still are scaremongering.

Secured core is a class of device security specifically intended to be highly locked down.

From https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/design/dev...:

> Secured-core PCs provide protections that are useful against sophisticated attacks and can provide increased assurance when handling mission-critical data in some of the most data-sensitive industries, such as healthcare workers that handle medical records and other personally identifiable information (PII), commercial roles that handle high business impact and highly sensitive data, such as a financial controller with earnings data.

> For general purpose laptops, tablets, 2-in-1’s, mobile workstations, and desktops, Microsoft recommends using Security baselines for optimal configuration. For more info, see Windows security baselines.

Re:Responsible stewardship of the UEFI Secure Boot ecosystem by raxxorraxor on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @07:36AM (#32068384)
But it is untrue that these devices are particularly secure, especially compared to the average linux distribution. This is Microsoft marketing and nothing else. On the contrary, the case for security is not to use MS systems because one of the largest threats for industry is industrial espionage and a lot of Microsoft components and data retention cannot be audited.

Boot sector attacks have become quite rare and a sensible threat analysis is the basis of good security. Otherwise you could sell any crap as security. Unplugging your keyboard stops a lot of attacks actually...

Re:Responsible stewardship of the UEFI Secure Boot ecosystem by MereInterest on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @07:18AM (#32068265)
I don't see why Microsoft working to make an extremely locked-down class of devices should be taken as evidence that Microsoft isn't working to lock down devices, or that they wouldn't have an incentive to lock down devices.
Re:Responsible stewardship of the UEFI Secure Boot ecosystem by Avamander on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @07:21AM (#32068280)
That's not what the person they replied to said though. Providing the means to harden a device do not mean you can't boot non-MS operating systems. It does show intent to harden devices yes, but not what was replied to.
Re:Responsible stewardship of the UEFI Secure Boot ecosystem by MereInterest on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @07:36AM (#32068385)
Placing additional obstacles to installing your choice of OS, even if each one is individually justified, leads to an veritable steeplechase of obstacles in doing so. By placing more and more restrictions on the default, each of which must be individually researched and disabled, fewer people are able to exercise their choice. There doesn't need to be a definitive deathblow if you can bleed away the opportunity to choose.
Re:Responsible stewardship of the UEFI Secure Boot ecosystem by Avamander on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @07:54AM (#32068538)
> Placing additional obstacles to installing your choice of OS, even if each one is individually justified, leads to an veritable steeplechase of obstacles in doing so.

It's a huge stretch to call a single toggle in UEFI an "obstacle" if you're already competent enough to install an OS from scratch. Maybe the focus should be on that, how to provide preinstalled Linux instead.

> each of which must be individually researched and disabled

Or you read the user manual.

Re:Responsible stewardship of the UEFI Secure Boot ecosystem by MereInterest on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @08:19AM (#32068774)
Hurdles like these are why "competent enough to install an OS" is considered a bar in the first place. I agree that it is good when OEMs offer Linux preinstalled, but that doesn't absolve Microsoft from adding obstacles in cases where OEMs do not.

Reading the user manual is a form of research that must be done. When software doesn't allow an action, and doesn't immediately explain what can be done to override the restriction, that's a form of additional research.

Re:Responsible stewardship of the UEFI Secure Boot ecosystem by AshamedCaptain on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @07:25AM (#32068305)
> we already said that its main purpose seemed to be to make booting of non-MS operating systems more complicated

is literally on the first paragraph of my comment.

Re:Responsible stewardship of the UEFI Secure Boot ecosystem by AshamedCaptain on Tuesday July 12, 2022 @07:35AM (#32068374)
Only when MS allows booting "vetted" non-MS OSes _with the same amount of effort_ as it takes to boot MS OSes (like what they do already in other devices) there is any minimal chance of believing this is for security, and not for pure market control.

If they wanted to have a setting to control whether to block non-MS OSes to boot, they could have put THAT as the hard-to-find option, rather than the opposite. They would not have needed to make an entire class of separate hardware whose only difference is apparently that by default it boots MS OSes only, and who knows how is being pushed behind the scenes.