News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Gruber on Flash Player for iPhone by silencio on Wednesday October 01, 2008 @06:03AM (#320558)
The problem with that part of the NDA is that Frotz is available on the app store and has been for a month or two. Frotz is an interactive fiction application (arguably interpreted) and also open source (gplv2, http://code.google.com/p/iphonefrotz/), two things technically incompatible with the NDA.

I don't really think Apple meant to include the likes of Frotz. Seems like the biggest issue is arbitrary rejection (as you mention), and not so much whether or not the NDA is strictly followed..exceptions made for applications that Apple sees nothing bad in. Of course, Flash would be a more direct threat to the App Store than IF, sooo...I have a feeling that even if there were some sort of loophole, Apple would reject it anyway. Shame, cause I'm not really interested in games, I just want to view some websites that don't have non-Flash fallback (sometimes for a legitimate reason) on my phone.

This also sucks from a developer perspective, but that particular issue has been discussed to excess everywhere without Apple yet doing something positive..

Re:John Gruber on Flash Player for iPhone by m_eiman on Wednesday October 01, 2008 @07:45AM (#320589)
How would GPL make an app incompatible with the NDA?
Re:John Gruber on Flash Player for iPhone by delackner on Wednesday October 01, 2008 @08:10AM (#320605)
I am just guessing, but it is currently against NDA for me to publish any source code to an iphone app that I write. If that app is based on GPL'd code, then I am obligated to make the source available, no? So the NDA and GPL would indeed seem to be at odds right now, unless I am not seeing something...
Re:John Gruber on Flash Player for iPhone by m_eiman on Wednesday October 01, 2008 @02:14PM (#320955)
Ah, then I see the problem. Seems like it's no longer a problem though, saw some headline about the nda being dropped.
Re:John Gruber on Flash Player for iPhone by attack on Thursday October 02, 2008 @12:16AM (#321404)
> against NDA for me to publish any source code to an iphone app that I write

Wow, that's awful.