News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by cldellow on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:20PM (#32047346)
A police officer "enforcing the law" is covered as law enforcement activity. That seems open to (mis)interpretation.

Although if you then get arrested, you'd fall under the exception for persons subject to police contact. So it all works out in the end!

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by refurb on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:28PM (#32047436)
Read the law. Police activity is defined as: questioning a suspect, conducting a search or arrest, or detaining an emotionally unstable person.

If you record and they start questioning you, you are exempt from 8 ft.

If they try to arrest you, you are exempt from 8 ft.

If they claim you are emotionally unstable, you are exempt from 8 ft.

If you are just a bystander, you need to stay 8 ft away from the police activity.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by vkou on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:40PM (#32047542)
So, when a cop walks up to you, and tells you to stop filming, and you tell him that you've read the law, and he tells you that he knows the law, and that you need to stop filming, or he will arrest you, who do you think will come out the winner of this curbside legal debate?

What do you think will happen to you?

What do you think will happen to the officer when we discover that his legal interpretation is incorrect?

The police don't actually need to know the law they are enforcing. And it's no sweat off their backs when they are wrong about the details.

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by cldellow on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:44PM (#32047581)
> Read the law.

I did, or at least tried to. That's why I put "enforcing the law" in quotes.

Maybe I read the wrong law? In https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/laws/0376.pdf, the definition of "law enforcement activity" includes this, from section E(2):

> CONDUCTING AN ARREST, ISSUING A SUMMONS OR ENFORCING THE LAW

My point is that "enforcing the law" seems like a very broad umbrella. Prior to this law being written, I think I'd be on OK ground if I was filming an arrest from 10 feet away and an unrelated police officer came up to me and told me to stop.

Now, it's less clear to me. The officer who comes up and tells me to stop clearly thinks he is enforcing the law. Am I now breaking the law if I don't stop recording?

Re:New Arizona law makes it illegal to film within 8 feet of... by uhnnXTvPE7bNkxj on Sunday July 10, 2022 @02:38PM (#32047524)
- Police begin questioning a suspect.

- You begin recording from 8 ft away.

- Police continue questioning the suspect, but move 1 ft towards you.

- You're now breaking the law.