News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by the_third_wave on Sunday July 10, 2022 @09:00AM (#32044317)
Use sand [1] instead of water and you'll be able to store a lot more energy in a limited area. Water can't be heated above 98°C at atmospheric pressure which puts a limit on how much energy can be stored per m³ while sand can be heated above 1000°C without problems. Add enough insulation and you'll be able to store enough heat to warm your house through the long winter. Sand is cheap, non-corrosive and doesn't freeze or boil [2]. The specific heat for sand (830 J/g K) is markedly lower than that for water (4000 J/g K) but the density is ~50% higher. Together with the much higher temperature spectrum this translates to a higher capacity per m³.

[1] https://polarnightenergy.fi/technology

[2] it can boil - silicon boils at 3265°C - but it is hard to see how such a temperature can be reached

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by wongarsu on Sunday July 10, 2022 @10:52AM (#32045286)
> doesn't freeze

In the sense that something that is frozen can't freeze. Apparently the melting point of sand is about 1700°C, so 1000°C sand indeed should handle about the same as 20°C sand or -100°C sand. That does sound rater neat for a large scale setup.

In a small-scale setup the convection currents, easy handling and lower insulation requirements of a water setup would probably still win out.

Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by fpoling on Sunday July 10, 2022 @12:12PM (#32045976)
If water tank holds water above 70C, it’s safety requirements make it significantly more expensive. Plus water close to the boiling temperature is rather corrosive. So I cannot rule out that even for small scale sand setup will be cheaper.
Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by flaviut on Sunday July 10, 2022 @09:33AM (#32044588)
Residential water heaters, at least in the USA, don't typically go above 60°C. So there's room to grow here, at least for now, without building a more exotic, and therefore expensive, system.
Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by tpm on Sunday July 10, 2022 @10:27AM (#32045065)
And the reason they don't go much higher could be that at higher temps water hardness starts depositing water stone on the heating element and lining.
Re:Is the smart grid all hot air? by goodpoint on Sunday July 10, 2022 @10:44AM (#32045223)
There's nothing exotic in a storage heater. They've been extremely common in UK for many decades.

A resistor, some bricks and some insulation. If anything they are too rudimentary.