News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI are taking jobs by mikeash on Sunday November 06, 2011 @07:04PM (#3204358)
This is just my uninformed opinion, but I think a lot of it has fallen victim to keeping up with the Joneses, and a lot of the rest to employers not being willing to give decent terms to part timers.

People could get by with a much smaller salary (or keep the same salary but save a ton of it) by having an older car, a smaller house, less fancy food, etc. but everybody else has nicer things. I see people buying really nice cars on credit and then they don't have much time to drive it recreationally because they spend all their time working to pay for it. "Well there's your problem!"

For the other side, let's say I make $X but only need $X/2 to live. Try finding an employer who will let you work half time for $X/2. It's pretty tough, especially if you make $X at something "professional", rather than, say, digging ditches. Worse, for Americans, is the current link between employment and health care. Half-time employment generally means having to buy your own health insurance, which doesn't come cheap.

In short, it seems like it's pretty hard to work less and make less, and when you do work full time and make good money, it's very tempting to spend a larger portion of it on luxuries.

Re:AI are taking jobs by thmcmahon on Sunday November 06, 2011 @08:02PM (#3204493)
There is an interesting article on Bloomberg about this exact thing. Americans have converted the extra productivity into consumer possessions, while other countries (read Scandinavia/Northern Europe) have converted them into increased leisure time.

Have a look:

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-11-03/americans-work-too-...

Re:AI are taking jobs by marvin on Monday November 07, 2011 @01:15AM (#3205234)
I was about to say this. Also, in Scandinavia the salaries _have_ indeed kept pace with increases in productivity. In Norway, you can earn a decent living as a checkout clerk. It seems as if the business owners here have actually passed on most of the savings to their workers. I'm pretty sure this is exclusively a cultural phenomenon - a sense of solidarity and cooperation which the larger part of US culture does not have. (I'm not meaning to bash the United States here, but this view is compounded by the fact that American employee-employer relationships seem a lot more antagonistic and imbalanced).

There are also less super-rich people here since people are overall taxed more. The oil industry also adds to the general income level, but this doesn't explain the entire effect. I'm pretty sure the same can be observed, in Sweden and Finland.

Re:AI are taking jobs by wycats on Monday November 07, 2011 @12:37AM (#3205157)
I have a better explanation. Wages have not even remotely kept pace with productivity, so most people do not see the benefits of increased overall productivity.

http://rationalrevolution.net/images/EPI_Productivity_vs_Com...

Re:AI are taking jobs by true_religion on Monday November 07, 2011 @12:57AM (#3205200)
I'm curious.... if productivity increases rapidly in all sectors then how are wages supposed to increase as well?

The theory is that employees should be paid more for producing more value per head. However if everyone produces more then wages can't go up without a corresponding increase in prices.

The alternative is reduced prices, new improved goods and services, and a steady wage giving the misleading sentiment of "everything is getting better, but I'm still being paid the same".

Re:AI are taking jobs by mikeash on Monday November 07, 2011 @05:00PM (#3208364)
Why do prices have to go up with productivity? To take a toy example, let's say that the entire economy consists of nothing but producing TVs, and that enough TVs are produced for each person to have one TV per year.

Now some massive productivity increase comes along and doubles output with the same workers. Now you're producing enough TVs for each person to have two TVs per year. Either the price of TVs will drop by 50%, or salaries will double. (Or half of the workforce will be fired....) Approximately. If everyone produces more then everyone has to be able to buy more, otherwise there's no reason to have the additional production in the first place.

Re:AI are taking jobs by tomjen3 on Monday November 07, 2011 @07:47AM (#3206041)
If that is the case, then you would expect to be able to make more money by starting your own business, because you start to reap all the rewards (and take on more of the risk).

My theory? Well somebody has to pay for all the useless people (Washington employes a ton of them and so do nearly all large companies in the world).

Re:AI are taking jobs by DavidSJ on Sunday November 06, 2011 @07:33PM (#3204417)
For the other side, let's say I make $X but only need $X/2 to live. Try finding an employer who will let you work half time for $X/2. It's pretty tough, especially if you make $X at something "professional", rather than, say, digging ditches.

Rather than working ~20 hours a week, work ~40 hours a week, half your life.

Re:AI are taking jobs by gvb on Sunday November 06, 2011 @09:55PM (#3204770)
...except nobody can tell me accurately when half of my life is over so I can retire at the right time.

Note particularly that statistics only work when applied to large enough populations. I will not be 70% dead at 70, I'll either be 100% dead or 0% dead.

http://jerryjousting.blogspot.com/2011/04/statistical-single...

Re:AI are taking jobs by yummyfajitas on Sunday November 06, 2011 @10:50PM (#3204900)
...except nobody can tell me accurately when half of my life is over so I can retire at the right time.

So work 40 hours/week for until you pile up enough money to buy a lifetime annuity, and let the insurance company do the averaging over large populations.

Re:AI are taking jobs by mikeash on Sunday November 06, 2011 @08:44PM (#3204608)
That's certainly more viable, but requires much more discipline (to avoid spending the extra money too early) and is probably less beneficial as well, due to diminishing returns and such.
Re:AI are taking jobs by a3camero on Sunday November 06, 2011 @09:48PM (#3204760)
Another factor: taxes.

$60k in one year is taxed at a higher rate than $30k/yr for each of two years.

RRSPs in Canada mitigate this... But you're probably still better off with $X/2 income.

Re:AI are taking jobs by nradov on Sunday November 06, 2011 @10:17PM (#3204816)
Look at it from the employer's perspective: in professional and technical occupations a half time worker isn't much cheaper than a full time worker due to benefits, training, administrative overhead, office space, PCs, etc.