News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI are taking jobs by Permit on Sunday November 06, 2011 @06:38PM (#3204279)
The problem is that there are not a lot of people capable of doing engineering/programming jobs. It is one thing to make the transition from a farmer to a factory worker, but another entirely to move from a factory worker to an engineer.

The learning curve for the jobs that may be created might be too steep for those whose jobs were displaced.

Re:AI are taking jobs by ericd on Sunday November 06, 2011 @06:49PM (#3204321)
True, I think creating high quality, cheap/free reeducation programs are one of the most important challenges facing us today.
Re:AI are taking jobs by nkassis on Sunday November 06, 2011 @07:05PM (#3204364)
But do you believe everyone is capable of that kind of work? Even with great education some things require talent at a certain level. The higher level the job the more dependent it is on talent in my view.
Re:AI are taking jobs by ericd on Sunday November 06, 2011 @09:14PM (#3204680)
Not everyone, but for every type of person I can think of, there's a different type of job that makes sense for them. If they're good with their hands, there are many things that will be hard to automate the repair of due to customization. If they're very persuasive, they can probably work in sales. If they're creative or artistic, there's a large need for good visual design.

If you find a way to make the marginal cost of educating someone near 0, then many more people might discover things that they're good at that they wouldn't have had the chance to otherwise.

I think this requires some socialist-style changes to what the govt. is willing to support, though, since many people can't afford to take time off. If this was bundled with unemployment benefits or welfare, though, I think it could be very powerful.

As leverage increases, the wealth disparity will almost certainly grow, just because some people will be able to create much more wealth than others. Not sure how to deal with that.

Re:AI are taking jobs by maeon3 on Sunday November 06, 2011 @06:55PM (#3204340)
Yes, the cotton pickers will need to be forced to go to high school and learn something that hasn't been automated. To the argument that this can't be done, take away their food, they will adapt. Mercy can be used in exceptional cases.

I don't like the argument: "This human has such an aversion to learning that they must be supported forever like a pet". I suppose you wait for them to die and the problem solves itself. They can learn, they just have been positively reinforced to not learn.

Re:AI are taking jobs by _delirium on Sunday November 06, 2011 @07:16PM (#3204391)
If the only reason a significant portion of society will participate in it is because they will literally die if they don't, i.e. it's a requirement for absolute minimum existence, that's a pretty sad place to have your society. That's basically "3rd-world subsistence farming" level of civilization. For some people, possibly even worse; there are some people who do badly in desk jobs who'd be perfectly capable subsistence farmers (if it were possible for them to acquire any land to farm).
Re:AI are taking jobs by Permit on Sunday November 06, 2011 @07:17PM (#3204392)
>take away their food, they will adapt.

Oh, undoubtedly. But they will go down the path of least resistance which will more than likely be a life of crime. It's also important to recognize that not everyone is cut out for intellectually demanding jobs. There is a wide variety of intelligence levels throughout society.

Re:AI are taking jobs by forensic on Sunday November 06, 2011 @09:56PM (#3204772)
I think the human race will reach the apex of its evolution when all the social darwinists die off.
Re:AI are taking jobs by bluedanieru on Sunday November 06, 2011 @10:26PM (#3204839)
They'll adapt alright, but remember that the goal of the adaptation is to provide for themselves a quality of life that is comparable to that of their peers, not necessarily to contribute to society in a way that you would find useful. That is, they're just as likely to kill you in a riot and take your things, as they are to commit to a few years of school in their late thirties or forties.

People are not rational actors.

In a sense libertarian ideals are quite virtuous and moral depending on your values, but they're terribly impractical. They take as many liberties with human nature as does pure communism.

Re:AI are taking jobs by nickik on Monday November 07, 2011 @03:11AM (#3205433)
Well hard core libertarians that are Anarchocapitalists maybe but in a system where you have working law (working like its working now) its more likly that people start learing to do something usefull then just going on a killing spree.
Re:AI are taking jobs by bluedanieru on Monday November 07, 2011 @06:27AM (#3205833)
The issue is whether they will even be able to, and what to do with them if they can't. It's one thing to say to one person 'well you didn't study hard enough or just aren't smart, we don't have anything for you to do and you'll never find employment again'. It's quite another to say that to tens of millions of people in the first world, and eventually hundreds of millions worldwide. I'm not sure that's where we're headed, but if we are as this article suggests, our institutions and way of life will not survive.
Re:AI are taking jobs by nickik on Monday November 07, 2011 @09:07AM (#3206265)
I just think that even with 40 you can learn something new. That said, I am in faver of a strong social stat to help these people.