Re:Monitoring tiny web services
by Spivak on Saturday July 09, 2022 @09:43PM
(#32041107)
503 doesn’t map well to me meaning “you performed a successful GraphQL query but the result is that the thing you tried to query is missing.”
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Yes that would be 404.
Similar to how there's no difference between "there's no /pets/" or "there is no /pet/15", they are both 404 for /pets/15
400 is also a good code for "your query doesn't make sense". Anything but 200 really.
Re:Monitoring tiny web services
by AdieuToLogic on Sunday July 10, 2022 @05:52AM
(#32043258)
While using HTTP status codes could work for GraphQL payloads which have only one operation in them, this approach would not work for those which have multiple[0].
0 - http://spec.graphql.org/October2021/#sec-Executing-Requests
207 has been used for that for decades. GraphQL looks like it's been implemented by someone who thought 200 and 404 were the only possible codes.
Re:Monitoring tiny web services
by AdieuToLogic on Sunday July 10, 2022 @08:28PM
(#32050776)
> 207 has been used for that for decades.
That's a WebDAV status code.
> GraphQL looks like it's been implemented by someone who thought 200 and 404 were the only possible codes.
Maybe. Or maybe they decided that a 2xx status would be interpreted as "success" by a non-trivial set of libraries and/or systems. Either way, take it up with the standards committee :-).