Before, your neighborhood's voters were homeowners who benefit from rising property values; after, they're renters who benefit from falling rents.
I've heard that Germany has more of this renting situation but no idea about the politics of housing supply over there.
In Seattle, for instance, municipal elections are on odd-numbered years. As a result, get out the vote operations that tend to increase renter turnout during presidential elections don’t have much impact on local elections.
We had a vote in the 90s that reduced housing supply considerably, “Citizens Alternative Plan.” It was a February special election with 23% turnout. 15% of Seattle voters downzoned the city.
This, however, does not mean it is causal. Just because it's the case at the moment does not mean it would be the case if homeownership dropped 50%.
There are many studies on homeownership and voting. I recommend the book “The Homevoter Hypothesis” if you’d like to start informing yourself about these issues!
I agree that most people investing in real estate aren't hoping for the underlying asset to significantly appreciate in value. Real estate pays significant dividends (more than stock), and you can be confident that it will provide a hedge against inflation.
Owning real estate also has a lot of tax advantages over stock (you can write off upkeep expenses and you can do a 1031 exchange, for example).
The financial industry is moving away from the northeast to the south, primarily Florida, Texas, and the Carolinas.
High rents, taxes, and property prices make people and businesses run away.
4% inflation per year (the most common estimate I see in the US) means 3x over 30 years doesn't even break even (1.04**30 ≈ 3.24).
I often wonder how much people obsessed with home prices rising (in the US at least) take this into account. How much housing mania is fueled by people getting excited about gains that aren't as real as they think?
* Jan 2007 price (inflation adjusted to 2022): GBP 243,199
* Jan 2022 price (actual): GBP 273,762
So it seems that in the UK at least the prices do seem to grow ahead of inflation. And the starting price we're talking about here is after a long, sustained housing bubble and was already quite unaffordable for many. Further still I think many people's wages have kept pace with inflation.
So looking at the raw price changes doesn't tell the whole story, but the whole story is still quite grim.
[0] = https://www.statista.com/statistics/751605/average-house-pri...
[1] = https://www.worlddata.info/europe/united-kingdom/inflation-r...
Inflation: 243,000/177,000-1=37%
House: 274,000/177,000-1=54%
In 2007 the yearly wage for a 22-29 year old was 20,000 pounds, in 2021 it was 26,000:
https://www.statista.com/statistics/802196/full-time-annual-...
26,000/20.000-1= 30%
If you try with an higher income, let's say 30-39, respectively 26,000 and 33,000
33,000/26,000-1= 27%
I think we can say that average houses have appeciated almost double average wages in these 15 years, which is the essence of the crazyness about houses being not affordable to most, and - as you said - it's not like in 2007 houses were cheap, data for a longer period show even more how young people then could actually buy a house and now it has become impossible:
https://landregistry.data.gov.uk/app/ukhpi/browse?from=1990-...
> Further still I don't think many people's wages have kept pace with inflation
But yeah either way - houses were expensive, and have only gotten more unaffordable as inflation outpaced wage growth and house prices outpaced both. Wild.
In a world where productivity is somewhat slowing after massive growth, people are taking to rent seeking activity and the disincentives aren’t there to encourage productive behavior.
Why buy and sell when you can buy, charge rent, and pass down to your kids?