Twitter is of course currently known as a source of Truth and Harmony.
"anything not illegal is allowed" sounds decent to me; if you want stuff illegal, make it illegal. If you want unwritten laws dreamt up by anonymous elites and enforced for random reason, go talk to Tipper Gore and the PMRC.
Try to talk about popular movies are TV shows and you get things like this on such sites [1]. Want to discuss an episode of PBS Space Time such as this one [2]. Don't be surprised if this is the discussion you get [3].
What almost always happens on such forums is that the people there who aren't racists, sexists, antisemites, inane conspiracy theorists etc., leave, and the forum ends up being largely just such people.
[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20201225021055/https://voat.co/v...
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RlXdsyctD50
[3] https://web.archive.org/web/20201223123156/https://voat.co/v...
Voat suffered from a flood of toxicity caused by Reddit banning toxic behaviors. From what I could tell, it was practically uninhabited before.
Reddit itself was largely "anything not illegal is allowed" at the time (in part due to lax enforcement of the few rules they had), and was largely fine. The toxic communities sequestered themselves for the most part.
Twitter would probably be much the same. The greater issue they'd have is the same Reddit had; it's hard to sell any advertising on a site where you can't guarantee ads won't show up next to racist/sexist/etc diatribes.
And there are numerous forums where that standard is applied; Twitter just happens not to be one of them because they like money.
Any remotely reasonable approach here has the state deciding which attributes can be used for moderation decision and which can't, which also isn't feasible.
Can't you already do this on Twitter? You just need to mark it as sensitive.
> That spammers and bots can't be banned?
It would be like 4chan I assume, spam/bots are banned.
Twitter is based in the US, the 1st Amendment protects hate speech such as explicit support for genocide. I don't consider a social network full of genocide promotion to be a good thing.
The exceptions to this were carved out in a court case regarding Compuserve, which was a subscription-only service. The stare decisis in this instance is on far shakier ground than Roe was.
The compuserve case led to section 230 of the CDA being created, but again that doesn't have to do with Marsh v Alabama. To have that apply, you'd need to make the argument that Twitter both is, and intends to be a public square, and well, the fact that they have posted moderation policies makes it clear that they don't.
In contrast, the historical statements of Twitter make it very clear that they intended to be the public square, e.g. "free speech wing of the free speech party." Additionally, the assertions and decisions of the state in regards to social media indicate massive influence over politics that far exceeds any city street. They say people are denied their rights of free expression because Trump blocked them on Twitter, and that Russia successfully manipulated our elections because a few Russians bought a tiny amount of Facebook ads.
Sidewalks of random streets are considered to be "the public square" in US law (broadly because random streets are usually publicly owned. You need things like gates and signs and such to revoke such an assumption). The Marsh v. Alabama ruling relied on the fact that the town didn't try to make its streets un-square like, and in fact encouraged public square-like use!
Notable here is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lloyd_Corp._v._Tanner, which in the case of a private entity that isn't literally acting like a municipality, they can kick you out!
> In contrast, the historical statements of Twitter make it very clear that they intended to be the public square, e.g. "free speech wing of the free speech party."
You will be hard pressed to take a single statement, made by a minor executive who acts outside of US jurisdiction, in 2012, as superior to the actual user agreements that Twitter has (and had at the time) in the US.
What is free speech but that.....
> would have made Twitter an open forum for spreading lies and hate.
Like it isn't now. Twitter lets pretty much anything and everything except hate against specific subgroups they've decided are "protected". It really doesn't help there choices are entirely arbitrary with no internal consistency.
Genuinely interested, and not just trying to argue: how would you otherwise define free speech? It sounds like you think free speech should have defined limits - which surely means it's not free speech any more?
Voltaire was right when he said "Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities." And social media lets authoritarians push absurdities to millions of people. President Trump using Twitter has spread conspiracy theories more than 1700 times to his 67 million followers.
Freedom of speech is not freedom of reach. Sadly There will always be racists, misogynists, anti-Semites, and child abusers. We should not be giving bigots and pedophiles a free platform to amplify their views and target their victims.
Zuckerberg says people should decide what's credible, not tech companies. When 2/3rds of millennials have not heard of Auschwitz how are they supposed to know what's true? There is such a thing as objective truth. Facts do exist.
https://www.popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-ha...
Fire in a theatre came up in the context of squashing a protestor against the draft, from a judge who thought eugenics may have something going for it.
Just let it die. Please.
Speech is transmission.
Reach is landing at a receiver.
Substituting /dev/null in place of a human being does not satisfy speech having occurred. A concordance must be reached between the speaker and at least one other individual.
That's what free speech is, whether or not you agree that such a policy of unrestricted free speech is constructive or beneficial.
Also disagree that such unrestricted free speech is constructive or beneficial. Sacha Baron Cohen explains it best: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymaWq5yZIYM
I am so tired of seeing this overplayed urban myth. The precedent you mention was set by Schenck v. United States in 1919, but it was partially overturned later in Brandenburg v. Ohio in 1969 [0]. Which is the part that people who bring up this myth every time conveniently forget about.
So no, you can yell "fire" in a crowded theater or whatever else you want, as long as it doesn't meet the legal standard for imminent lawless action (e.g., a riot). And the legal standard for imminent lawless action is much higher than you think it is.
0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_the...
So there is no absolute free speech then. Which is the point of bringing up the "fire" example.
If you're a visitor in my house there is no free speech at all. If you say something I don't like I'll legally kick you out. Private companies such as Twitter and Facebook have the same right. Their platform, their rules.
No idea how this is relevant to your claim that "yelling fire in a crowded theater isn't allowed under free speech". It is legally allowed under free speech, it isn't a crime, despite what a lot of people claim. The theater might kick you out or ban you, but that has nothing to do with free speech.
It's very funny how those things came to be known as code words for the *true* offenses, which we all know very well.
What a waste of perfectly good words that used to have meaning.
i think you are referring to twitter.com
imo this is pretty bad for twitter the company. they’ve been flat for years, they’re current valuation is less than in 2013. they’ve lost the plot a while ago and seem to have been in a managed decline, probably because they were looking for buyers.
> and good for the world
you are overestimating how many people care about twitter outside of the US.
Wouldn't he look to be a hypocrite otherwise? [1]
[1] https://nypost.com/2022/05/31/elon-musk-calls-out-bill-gates...
The headline is: "Elon Musk Sells $8.5 Billion of Tesla Shares After Deal to Buy Twitter"
The deal to buy Twitter gave Musk an excellent cover for selling billions of dollars' worth of TSLA. He doesn't need to sell all of TSLA. He sold a massive amount. If he didn't have this cover it would have looked like he thinks TSLA is overvalued (which in fact it is).
Both Gates and Musk sold TSLA. Gates sold borrowed shares, Musk sold shares he owned. That's the only difference. Of course Musk still has tons of TSLA remaining. But that doesn't change the fact that both Gates and Musk did the same thing (sell TSLA) and yet Musk criticized Gates for it. What a hypocrite!
My guess is Musk never intended to buy Twitter. He needed an excuse for dumping billions of dollars' worth of TSLA at its peak (while at the same time faulting Bill Gates for shorting TSLA), and his proposal to buy Twitter provided a convenient cover.