Re:Are We Wayland Yet?
by yjftsjthsd-h on Friday July 08, 2022 @01:43AM
(#32023736)
>> Xorg [...] allowed arbitrary stuff to build on top.
> Same as wayland.
No, because Wayland puts everything on the compositor. X11 let me run the same screenshot tool on GNOME, KDE, and dwm. In wayland, the only way to support GNOME, KDE, and sway is to add multiple backends. In X11, window managers and compositors were interchangeable and orthogonal; in Wayland, the "window manager" is subsumed into the compositor (now mandatory), which is the display server. I really like keynav. AFAICT, implementing an equivalent in Wayland requires integration into each compositor. There's still a monolith, but it got moved up the stack to a place where it prevents piecemeal environments.
Re:Are We Wayland Yet?
by throwawaylinux on Friday July 08, 2022 @05:44AM
(#32024906)
I don't see anything you wrote that means you can't build arbitrary stuff on top of Wayland.
Same as wayland.
> If wayland results in a monoculture of desktop environments, that will be a regression.
It isn't, because you have everything that's ported to Wayland _and_ everything that's ported to X11. So it's the opposite of a monoculture.