Thank you for clarifying! From zfs-allow.8 docs Example 2 [1] it looks like it should be possible, but I guess there are important details omitted from that document that make such a design nonviable in your case. I'm glad to hear that you are using system designs vetted by zfs experts.
[1]: https://openzfs.github.io/openzfs-docs/man/8/zfs-allow.8.htm...
So, basically, you need to be root to fully manage your own zpool ... and if you need to be root, you need to be in a VM. In our case, we use bhyve and we have had very good success.
We have this on very good authority - Allan Jude of Klara Systems has helped us audit the entire setup and there is not, unfortunately, a lighter way to do it.