I don’t love background checks but I have seen a situation where a person previously convicted for embezzlement was hired as a controller.
No background check was performed and the person drained the bank account ($XMM) at their new job before being caught when checks started bouncing.
I don't really give a shit if someone was arrested for a drug offense (or many other offenses), and knowing that information brings up all sorts of complications, to the degree that it outweighs the value of knowing relevant stuff (largely because genuinely relevant things from a background check are rare).
Hiring managers should not be looking at BGC material.
And what kind of employee will you lose if you set such restrictions?
In some countries (e.g. US) people are convicted all the times for things they haven't done. Or have done but which is in the past and really irrelevant for the job.
On the other time people are not convicted for a lot of kinds of white collar fraud all the time, too.
One of the problems with not doing background checks is ex post facto if you do have problems with an employee, and it turns out that you could have discovered them with a background check, then that can figure into your liability.