News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Bi-directional links between any two apps, what do you think?

The idea of bi-directional links started to get popular beginning in 2019. Products such as RoamResearch, Obsidian, Logseq, and Notion applied this feature to link internal pages. I was thinking: wouldn't it be great if bi-directional links could be used across apps (say: Slack and Notion). Instead of switching apps (causing loss of focus), people can navigate through apps with links in the order of their workflow. I am putting my effort into implementing this feature on my upcoming product; what do you all think?
( 4 comments | 2 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Bi-directional links between any two apps, what d... by zhangruinan on Thursday July 07, 2022 @06:34AM (#32012240)
Bi-directional links establish a two-way connection between pages. This enables you to browse in either direction: follow a link to its destination, but then also browse backlinks, which are all the pages that link to the current page.

In practice, if you copy the link of a Slack thread to the Notion document, there is only a one-way link from Notion to Slack. If the link also enables you to navigate from Slack to Notion, it is a bi-directional link.

Re:Ask HN: Bi-directional links between any two apps, what d... by keikobadthebad on Thursday July 07, 2022 @03:02AM (#32010757)
I think you should clearly explain what a 'bidirectional link' is and looks like in this context if you're hoping for feedback. I never heard of any of those products.

List of links to referring pages on each page? Something else?

Re:Ask HN: Bi-directional links between any two apps, what d... by zhangruinan on Thursday July 07, 2022 @06:35AM (#32012247)
here is the definition according to google and an example:

Bi-directional links establish a two-way connection between pages. This enables you to browse in either direction: follow a link to its destination, but then also browse backlinks, which are all the pages that link to the current page.

In practice, if you copy the link of a Slack thread to the Notion document, there is only a one-way link from Notion to Slack. If the link also enables you to navigate from Slack to Notion, it is a bi-directional link.

Re:Ask HN: Bi-directional links between any two apps, what d... by brudgers on Thursday July 07, 2022 @11:15AM (#32015144)
I think you should ask your users, rather than asking HN.

If you don't have users, then bidirectional links are not a feature users want so find some users first.

Good luck.