Re:Can Anyone Really Create Jobs?
by rwl on Saturday November 05, 2011 @12:12PM
(#3200073)
Huh? Aren't government employees paid in the same currency as employees in the private sector? Don't those employees spend that currency largely in the private sector? If those people wouldn't otherwise be employed, how are their jobs not "helping the economy"?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
You are propounding the Broken Window Fallacy. To discover the flaw in your reasoning see:
It looks to me like this is only a fallacy on the assumption that government employees are like glaziers fixing broken windows: absorbing value that, but for a loss, could otherwise be put to another use. It is that assumption that I meant to question, though I see I did not express the point adequately.
Re:Can Anyone Really Create Jobs?
by yummyfajitas on Saturday November 05, 2011 @04:41PM
(#3200859)
If you wish to question such an assumption, you need to show that government employees produce something of value, not that they consume something of value.