News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by littlestymaar on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @05:59AM (#31998806)
> 4. If my life is at stake, I pull the lever to save myself.

I find this answer really interesting, because in the entire corpus, this was the most morally unambiguous question of all, and the answer is diametrically opposed to yours.

Would have I the courage to do so in real life, I don't know, and it's probable that I would not. But from a moral perspective it's damn clear: the only people I am unambiguously allowed to kill to save someone else is myself. Killing someone to save someone else is a moral dilemma as it makes me take someone's life, but killing myself isn't.

Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by darkerside on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @06:36AM (#31999060)
Interestingly, I had almost the opposite reaction. In the absence of information, I don't know how these people got here or why. Maybe they're being executed as criminals, maybe they are suicide attempts, maybe they are truly heinous people in the hands of a Just God.

But, I do know, if it's me on the track, I don't want to die. It's almost the only truly inarguable choice. With everything else, you think you know best for other people. With that one, you just know you don't want to die.

Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by littlestymaar on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:50AM (#32001856)
I think you're mixing up two things: willingness to die, and the morality of the sacrifice.

Most of us will be scared shitless if we were in that situation, and I'm pretty sure the majority (me included) will act as a coward. But nobody would blame them, because we all know we would likely have done the same.

But on the other hand, we praise the heroes who sacrifice themselves because we recognize that they did the right thing, no matter how much it costed them.

Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by beeboop on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @02:39PM (#32005041)
I think we have the right to save ourselves with the options we have available. I didn't tie these people to the rails, I didn't set the trolley in motion towards people tied on rails, I'm not the one that had any sort of input on what the safety systems should be for the trolley. If I pull the lever to save myself and 5 people die, they die as a result of circumstance and insufficient safeguards of the trolley system itself.
Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by YPPH on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @06:10AM (#31998882)
I also find it interesting. I wonder how extreme the parent comment would go? Would they sacrifice themselves to save, say, a million people?

A solipsistic view might say that those people are part of our own consciousness. If we let them die, we continue to exist. If we sacrifice ourselves, all of us cease to exist since they are just manifestations of our consciousness. As Christopher Hitchens once said, beware of solipsism...

Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by addandsubtract on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @08:40AM (#31999940)
> I wonder how extreme the parent comment would go? Would they sacrifice themselves to save, say, a million people?

On the other hand, how many people would you need to save to sacrifice yourself? 5? 2? 1? Does that one person need to be younger than you? Not disabled? Not a criminal?

Re:Absurd Trolley Problems by blabberwocky on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:58AM (#32001962)
This doesn’t seem morally unambiguous at all, and in fact society reached the opposite conclusion for many centuries in outlawing suicide but allowing some killing of others (e.g., the executioner tasked with killing the person convicted of attempting suicide).

An equally compelling principle might be that the only person I know to be worth saving is myself.