Re:Absurd Trolley Problems
by paxys on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:31AM
(#31997066)
You are discounting the simple possibility that 70% of respondents do not have any significant "life savings" to speak of.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Not to mention a lot of people measure account their wealth in more than just money.
Reminds me of Richard Posner, former Chief Justice of the Seventh Appelate court. His essay on how poor people have no wealth so you need the threat of prison to keep them in line. And how middle class people you only need the threat of impoverishment to keep them in line. So you can just fine them. And wealthy people only need the threat of loss of reputation to keep them in line.
Which is to say Posner is an idiot that knows nothing of poor people. Because all an honest poor person owns is his reputation. Where Musk... when you are that wealthy someones always going to overlook your transgressions.
Evidently he also didn't know anything about rich people. If they manage to damage their reputations then they figure a good PR firm and some contributions to the right places will take care of that for them.
Re:Absurd Trolley Problems
by darkerside on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @06:49AM
(#31999142)
I think it used to be true. The Musks and Trumps have, like Neo in the Matrix, decided they have total control over their actions with no regard for mere perception any longer. Some people think the old framework is still valid, and others think it no longer applies.
People operating on different sets of facts!
Re:Absurd Trolley Problems
by mrcartmeneses on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:32AM
(#31997076)
100%. I have no savings so it was an easy pull
Risky play, if I’m lucky and inflation goes up 1000% I’ll seem downright smart for counting on the breakdown of society!
I have the ability to re-earn my wealth. I can't undo death.
But perhaps your wealth would put you in a better situation to save additional lives in the future. It's a tough moral question.
Re:Absurd Trolley Problems
by kretaceous on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @04:02AM
(#31998064)
Exactly what I thought!