I understand that neither NIST nor NSA have designed these schemes, but isn't NIST the organization who picked these winning schemes after all? That's the impression I got, and my history of trusting what NIST picks, isn't the greatest, so I'd like to avoid that. I also understand that countless of people have reviewed the schemes as well, people from all around the world with different types of experience. It's still hard to shake off something that essentially boils down to a feeling: "trust".
Thank you for providing some alternatives in your final paragraph, for the uneducated plebs like myself.
Edit to add: if the authorship of the submitters is as above reproach as we are led to assume, why can that not be the case for the NIST decision panel itself?
Edit 2: answered already elsewhere: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31993896
The closest analog to NIST I can think of is ECRYPT and the eSTREAM contest. It produced interesting work and you could follow it in much the same way people followed these last two NIST competitions. But for PQ KEMs, it's likely that NIST's will be the "competition of record".