Re:Uncle Bob and Silver Bullets (2017)
by BurningFrog on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @12:29PM
(#31990337)
Sound about right!
I think the fallacy of the "Poltergeist Pattern" is to optimize solely on the - in itself valuable - metric of short simple methods, without consider anything else, like the complexity of using or reading the resulting code.
Ousterhout is saying that we really want deep classes, i.e. the complexity of the implementation a construct hides should be considerably larger than the complexity it takes to use it. Which, at least to me, basically says "search for good abstractions". And what you're describing strikes me as a good way not to achieve that.
Of course, there's considerable wiggle room in that mental model, and one could still endlessly squabble about how (not) to break up the implementation.
[1]: https://www.amazon.com/Philosophy-Software-Design-John-Ouste...