News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vets today are like doctors yesterday by ghufran_syed on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @07:51AM (#31987077)
"Even so, never stick the pads on someone who isn't actually in cardiac arrest because if it gets it wrong it probably would drop them into cardiac arrest."

MD here, I strongly disagree - the AED is designed for use by minimally trained people. And the chances of a shock being wrongly administered is many times lower than the chance of saving a life if they are in a shockable rhythm.

I think it's really hard to definitively diagnose cardiac arrest in the first few seconds to minutes, even for some medical personnel - even if you have no cardiac output, a person often still has some residual apparent breathing ("agonal breathing") which often leads people to delay CPR, and delay applying the AED/monitor+defibrillator.

Perhaps we can agree there is no point placing it on patients who can talk to you? :) But if as an untrained person you applied it to every person who lost consciousness in front of you, you would do a lot more good than harm, with almost zero absolute risk of harm.

Re:Vets today are like doctors yesterday by Gordonjcp on Tuesday July 05, 2022 @11:10AM (#31989150)
> Perhaps we can agree there is no point placing it on patients who can talk to you?

Yes, that's kind of what I was getting at.

Or to put it another way "don't fuck about with the AED because it's not a toy and its safety systems are not infallible". If you stick it on someone unresponsive - and you've got enough reason to suspect they're in a shockable state - it probably won't make them any worse.

Like my old trauma instructor used to say, "You can't make dead any deader!"