Re:Bankruptcy, not bailout, is the right answer
by byrneseyeview on Tuesday September 30, 2008 @12:57PM
(#319745)
It doesn't make sense to arbitrarily decide that, if there are two proposals, the answer is to do a little of both. In financial markets, that's often the worst possible course of action. With S&Ls in the early 80's, for example, Congress could have allowed them to fail, or nationalized them. Instead, Congress gave them extra deposit insurance and deregulated their lending -- which caused them to make lots of stupid loans, backed by government insurance. Similarly, California half-deregulated their energy market, which ended up bankrupting their power companies and costing their consumers extra.
Re:Bankruptcy, not bailout, is the right answer
by biohacker42 on Tuesday September 30, 2008 @01:09PM
(#319771)
The middle and compromise are not in and by themselves the right answer.
Moderation is often a far superior strategy then extremism, but a little of both is not a superior answer to the question: Is this circuit on or off?
The "middle is always right" attitude reminds me of the US media, which will often juxtapose facts and spin, then idly stand by, pointing out that both "extreme" positions are equally valid.
Re:Bankruptcy, not bailout, is the right answer
by swombat on Tuesday September 30, 2008 @02:29PM
(#319864)
Economics is not an on-off problem.
Re:Bankruptcy, not bailout, is the right answer
by biohacker42 on Tuesday September 30, 2008 @03:54PM
(#319956)
Never the less, compromising for the sake of compromising is by no means a smart strategy.
I am not enough of an economist or politician to be able to tell you in detail what the ideal compromise is in this situation, nor do I care to claim that I am.
What I do know, however, is things are not black and white. Baying for the banks' blood and shouting "liquidate!" is exactly what they did in 1929 and that kind of behaviour is even more reprehensible than the banks'.
Similarly, handing the banks a giant wad of cash with no strings attached is not right either.
The solution lies in the middle, as always.