PoW burns a lot of energy, but the algorithm has an elegant simplicity to it. Crucially, the _work_ is impossible to fake.
PoS (very roughly) means that the richest control the network... which seems reasonable. But suppose you decide to rewrite the blockchain to say you're the richest, do you then control the network? It's a circular loop, and defending against those kinds of attacks is dramatically more complex. I've been lightly following development and I get the sense they've been playing whack-a-mole with vulnerabilities and bugs since ~2016. It's hard to have confidence in the result.
Coming back down to earth, this is why ETH requires checkpoints[1], but PoW chains do not[2].
[1]: https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/consensus-mechanisms...
[2]: https://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/75733/why-does-b...
How is "[using] dramatically less carbon" more secure? What are the security implications?
> Since its inception, Ethereum has aimed to implement a proof-of-stake consensus mechanism, but doing this without sacrificing security and decentralization has taken years of focused research and development.
A rather notable criticism of PoS, and its variations, is that it /does/ sacrifice decentralization to achieve its aims. I know that much smarter people than me have been working on this, and I don't follow research into consensus algos super closely, but I haven't heard or read anything validating PoS as the silver bullet it's made out to be.