I’m not sure that’s how energy markets work… do you have any further reading? I’ve heard generally miners buy the cheapest electricity possible—typically oversupply that would otherwise be curtailed.
I don’t understand why Bitcoin mining is incompatible with emissions reduction. It sounds like an additional source of demand may make economical plants that otherwise could not be built.
Some years ago, there was a book published where the author systematically looked at the energy consumption (not just the of the UK and compared it to the total possible renewable energy sources therein. He found that even if you covered every hectare of the UK with solar panels, sent every raindrop through hydro power plants to extract energy as it runs to the sea, etc., it still would not provide enough renewable energy to satisfy UK consumption.
Switching existing energy sources to renewable isn't sufficient to avoid climate change; we need to reduce aggregate energy consumption. And that means that Bitcoin mining, adding a massive energy sink where one did not previously exist, is doing the exact opposite of what needs to be done.
In the book he tries to determine if renewables could support UK's energy needs. He estimated the UK consumes about 195 kWh per day per person (food, transporation, heating, miltary defense, ...)
If the UK massively invested in all the renewable options it stacked up to 180 kWh per day per person (obviously he provided lots of caveats).
His assumption on Solar PV was covering 5% of the UK land with 10% efficient PVs (about 200m2 per person). He estimated that could contribute 50kWh/d/p.
In the 14 years since the book was published it seems like Solar PV efficiency is now commonly 17-19%. So might only need to use 2.5% of the land.
The amount of misinformation around crypto energy usage has been out of control in the past few years. It's still weird to dip into an HN comment section and see people spreading the false claim that mining is powered by renewable energy sources that would otherwise go to waste (an absurd claim on every level) or that Bitcoin is somehow a "store of energy". The extreme energy inefficiency of cryptocurrencies is well-documented and doesn't even come close to any other financial system.
> Perhaps the goal shouldn't be to minimize energy use but to maximize energy output.
The real goal is to minimize harmful emissions. If we had some hypothetical infinite clean energy source then mining wouldn't be a big deal. However, even when mining is colocated with renewable energy sources, that renewable energy is prevented from going into the grid and offsetting fossil-fuel power plants.