Re:Piracy is Not Theft: Problems of a Nonsense Metaphor
by frobozz on Friday November 04, 2011 @10:08AM
(#3196093)
> "what if I slander you"...
An even more important example - What if I open up a competing business with better advertising and greater value for money? That deprives others of revenue, but is neither criminally nor civilly illegal, and only in certain cases could it even be considered immoral.
Take the example of a DVD you've already purchased for personal use. If I rip that to play on my unlicensed OS, is it theft? What if I rip the DVD so I can email a link to my brother, instead of shipping him the DVD? Calling this theft is pointless, unless the point is to unfairly frame the debate.