Tone is lost in text and I don't have much background. If I was thinking of contributing to Clojure, this post is reason enough to stay away from it.
Based on your explanation, I think Hickey should have simply ignored the user's post and let that be the end of it. I mentioned "blunt" response to individual contributions. That is quite different to a blanket statement with a "we don't owe you s... - f... off if you don't like it" vibe.
Without wanting to sound flippant or rude, I think they'd be cool with that. They're talking about contributions to the core language here. Not fixing typos in a README.
In mature projects like this, all the low-hanging fruit is done. You can't just take a notion some weekend and fire off a useful pull request. It requires an investment. To make a good contribution to Clojure you have to....
- clearly define the problem that needs to be solved
- get other people on the core team to agree that it needs to be solved
- document a number of ways to solve it, discuss with the community which one will work best
- let these ideas stew for a while, people might change their minds
The above constitutes 95% of the work and would typically take months rather than days. Once all that's done, coding up the implementation is the easy bit.That's a detail that, even if specifically was mentioned, would be overshadowed by the main sentiment.
But anyway, this is how we got to the point of Hickey writing this post:
- Heavy Clojure User received bunch of feedback from friends and colleagues asking why something hasn't been fixed yet in Clojure core
- Heavy Clojure User sees that bunch of stuff hasn't been fixed, so they take it on themselves to fix these issues and submit patches
- The workflow of "Submit patch -> Have Hickey review it and deny it -> Make changes -> Wait for Hickey again -> etc etc" was too slow for the Heavy Clojure User
- So Heavy Clojure User made their post describing "How to contribute to Clojure", blaming the core team for not working tightly enough with the community and spending enough time reviewing/accepting patches
- Hickey publishes this post titled "Open Source is Not About You" not entirely aimed at "Heavy Clojure User" but the community at large, while still being a reaction to that post by Heavy Clojure User
- Heavy Clojure User apologizes for the initial post, for tying Clojure with their own identity and explains a period of self-reflection has begun.