News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HTML5's time is back by lifthrasiir on Thursday November 03, 2011 @11:48PM (#3194864)
I'm so glad about this response from W3C (I do criticize the general bureaucracy of W3C though). In many aspects, I felt that the recent moves of the HTML living standard were much like that of XHTML2:

- Why do keep the redundant <a> element while we can add the href attribute to all elements?

- Why do keep <br> while we can generalize the line structure via <nl>? (NB: I'm not sure about the exact element name)

Is removing <time> in favor of <data> really different from these statements?

Re:HTML5's time is back by dhx on Friday November 04, 2011 @01:22AM (#3195027)
The problem with HTML is that it tries to simultaneously solve two completely different problems:

1) How do I provide data in a meaningful, semantic, machine-readable format?

2) How do I display data in a web browser, on a phone or in print? Do I use columns? What type of navigation options should I provide to the user in this instance?

XML solves (1). XSLT/HTML (as a UI layout description format only) can solve (2).

Attempts to merge the two concepts together will end in certain failure.

Re:HTML5's time is back by petervandijck on Friday November 04, 2011 @07:31AM (#3195648)
Yes, certain failure. That internet thing will never amount to anything :)

There's a saying about the perfect being the enemy of something, can't remember it though.