The article is most certainly popsci and written for laymen, but I don't think it is trash at all. Not sure why you think so. It highlights some very interesting discoveries and offers you a window to dive in and learn more things on the subject if you are interested.
I agree with you. This could be an interesting topic. But the article provides no substantive information. Anything that is learned will be in spite of this article, not because of it.
What you describe is the potential that I maintain this article fails to live up to.
> It's a very interesting observation in my opinion and asks important questions about how the modern lifestyle is affecting the biome. For instance, what happens if a pregnant mother takes antibiotics? Will a family of bacteria get killed off in that mother's evolutionary branch?
That’s a great question! But it isn’t in the article.
Or, perhaps we shouldn't print speculation about interesting topics unless we have the answers to the questions being discussed?
Or, print should be reserved objective facts?
I agree that hyperbole like "scary" are confusing to many people. But in this case, I think the scientist is appealing to slang in an effort to communicate with non-scientists.
This seems like an uncharitable take. I can't imagine how an alarmist approach is "100% valid" when there are not any known problems caused by this. The article is only stating that living in urban environments is correlated with a decrease (by A Lot) in gut microbes. Even if it is true that a significant decrease in gut microbes is a Bad Thing, the article does not argue that well. Indeed, it seems to intend to argue that with little or no substance.
> Consider [OP's] comment as feedback from an editor to the author.
If the comments are just criticisms about the content in the article then they seem apt. Many of the points hold up when I am critical about the article's arguments. It's possible to argue that position and also be in favor of publishing this information.
I don't think it takes very much imagination to understand why the loss of diversity in an ecosystem might have negative implications for that ecosystem.
For whatever it's worth to you, Science magazine is a companion to the extremely prestigious Science Journal and it often tries to summarize the research in the journal. The tiniest amount of searching shows that the biologist whose work is being summarized a is one of the leading experts in this area.
As I already said, it doesn’t largely do that. It mentions it in literally one paragraph that is itself mostly fluff.
The most substantive line is literally “with computers”:
> With computers, they were able to compile the fragments of DNA sequenced into whole genomes of the gut microbes present.
There’s no further mention of how these computers work or what they do or what is novel about them. And that’s the most interesting part of the piece.
I think when people see a difference in modern life versus traditional, and that difference was unexpected and unintended, that in itself is cause for concern. I don't need to believe claims about how important the gut biome is to the brain etc. But I would be surprised if the there weren't some consequence of the difference, and it seems like wishful thinking to suppose, as you do, that the consequences are benign.
I didn’t conclude that the effects are benign. I claimed that this article does nothing to assist me in deciding if they are.
Similarly, global warning is rising temperature, and we are trying hard to model the effects, but it's really all it is: models and guesses. We would much prefer if we could go back to the climate we were familiar with for the past 20,000 years. That one we were starting to understand to some extent. Now all bets are off
Whilst microbiome is a fascinating topic people are quick to lend unsubstantiated pet theories new credence, harboured by the topics nasence and complexity.
Anecdotally, logical fallacy bingo is a great actual game and I recommend everyone play
Life expectancy increase is mostly a factor of decreased death at birth or in early years. You dont see an exponential increase of 100 years old. People die at about the same age as before, give or take.
You correctly identify that it is unlikely your lifespan is increasing because the average gut bacteria diversity is decreasing, more likely they are simple correlated.
What did not changed is maximum longevity people have assuming they don't get sick or injured.
For this kind of statement about lifespan i assume that we remove all accidental deaths since they are just causing noise versus the actual lifespan
Your points are valid, don't get me wrong, but there is also a lot of research causally linking microbiome deficiencies with various health problems.
Also worth noting your shots seem more aimed at the journalist's style than the researcher's work. I for one, think this is super valuable and promising research
I’m sure there is. But it isn’t in this article. So reading this to learn about it is a waste of time.
> Also worth noting your shots seem more aimed at the journalist's style than the researcher's work.
That’s a correct assessment, yes.
> I for one, think this is super valuable and promising research
A good source for that conclusion may exist, but this isn’t it.
Worsening of the environment we live in impacts us in ways we cannot even imagine.
Scary is that we cannot go back, coz its financially impossible for most.
Larger populations, specialization of labor, and fortifications made city-states militarily superior to small bands of hunter-gatherers and allowed cities to dominate a surrounding region (at least until the modern horse). When a region was depleted of wild game then cities and their croplands were the most reliable source of food. Armies from city states would not infrequently raid and capture smaller groups of humans and bring them back to cities as slaves.
So cities were likely a forced choice, as smaller nomadic groups were forceably absorbed into the domains of city-states or repelled toward less hospitable lands.
Put it one way it's bad, put it one way its good. It's a choice with tradeoffs - I'm just pointing out that those tradeoffs aren't some uniquely new "collapse of our society" thing.
"People can't afford leaving city" suggest there is active price to be paid for ability to be somewhere - transport, house elsewhere being too expensive or some such. It does not even suggets opportunity cost.
Otherwise said, first sentence means people move to city because it is better for them economically. Second does not say anything about whether it is good for you, just that moving away would cost too much. Also, some people stayed in economicaly bad places, because they could not afford to move to the better place. Transport and initial housing pay was too much.
Riffing:
I think there’s a middle phrasing similar to “cities are the most efficient allocation of resources we have yet invented.”
Similar to the “democracy is the least bad system of government yet invented.”
There’s some corollary to survivorship bias at play here as well. Cities are an apparently natural consequence of human civilization so we know a lot about their flaws. But civilizations that didn’t migrate toward cities either failed or records of their existence was lost.
We do have some good mechanistic hypotheses, but most reviews fail to describe them because a lot of research is hand wavy. However, things are slowly reaching mainstream.
Let's consider type 1 diabetes (T1D), which is a common autoimmune disorder where beta cells in the pancreas get destroyed by your own immune system. T1D was rare a century ago, and we know from patient records that incidence increases rapidly whenever a society becomes industrialized. For example, take the Karelia region split between Finland and Russia. People on both sides of the border have the same genetic background. However, children on the Finish side have 10x more incidence of insulin autoantibodies [1]. Microbiomes on both sides are actually very different, with Russian children resembling ancient non-industrialized ones.
The immune system is essentially a huge distributed memory where individual cells recognize small protein or lipid fragments as self or foreign, and then collectively decide whether there is an infection in the particular microenvironment they are exploring. We know T1D typically begins because the immune system recognizes a particular insulin chunk, the amino acid sequence SHLVEALYLVCGERGFF, as foreign. In other more complex autoimmune disorders this part is less clear.
It turns out that many gut bacteria mimic that particular insulin chunk [2]. That probably gives these commensal bacteria the ability to survive and avoid immune responses, and it is a flag of the symbiotic relationship these bacteria have developed with higher organisms in the last 100 million years. Now, the bacterial ecosystem of a modern gut has a lot less diversity than it should and therefore it is very fragile. We don't know exactly what happens before T1D, but one possibility is that these bacteria grow too much in abundance and therefore initiate autoimmunity as T cells found in the pancreas of T1D patients can't distinguish between one protein chunk from these bacteria and insulin.
There are similar patterns in other autoimmune disorders like multiple sclerosis. This patent aims to edit bacterial mimics that cause autoimmunity using a CRISPR system in a pill [3].
[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4950857/ (Figure 1)
[2] https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.05.11.22274678v... (Extended Table 1)
[3] https://patents.google.com/patent/US11224621B2/en (see e.g. Example 4)
Are then not antibodies against gut bacteria a clear sign of a damaged gut barrier?
(FWIW there seem to be suspicions that Ankylosing Spondylitis is also caused by a certain type of bacteria being present _and_ getting into places such that antibodies against them are formed.)
There is a lot of literature that supports the role of gut bacteria inducing Tregs, and now there is also some evidence of epitope transport from the gut into the thymus.
Hence, I think these events might matter even if they are not very frequent.
But you could be right, and perhaps there's not really a relevant mutualistic relationship between host and commensals in terms of epitope crossreactivity.
This doesn't falsify the claim at all. Diabetes was first recorded 3500 years ago, and none of the other diseases on the list were literally invented by industrialization. Diseases of civilization refers (essentially) to diseases whose casualty rates dominate in societies of abundance and industrialization, by contrast to the predominance of (eg) infectious diseases in pre-industrial societies.
I do agree that it stands slightly apart from the rest of the examples, in that (eg) a contemporary hunter-gatherer still has a fair chance of getting cancer while they have a very low chance of diabetes/obesity. But it's pedantry to claim flatly that it doesn't qualify, especially given plenty of scientific usage[1][2][3] that contradicts the claim.
[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6362881/#:~:tex.... [2] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF00933491 [3] https://www.karger.com/Article/Abstract/323926
But it's scary because without gut bacteria we'd all be dead. We depend on them so much that I sometimes wonder if they're the host and we're the "parasite".
What you said about correlation v cause and such is spot on. And perhaps the article fails because of what you listed.
Nonetheless, losing half of something that our living depends doesn't feel like grounds for celebration. The fact that we just don't know, well that's concerning as well.
The article does not make reader scared at all. It does not call for any major action. It is about what kind of research that is being done and tl;dr to what they found. And then quotes from researchers most of them about "that research is really cool".
It is popularization article with excessively low amount of anything emotional. It is interesting article too. But you somehow want to to be scary and then blame it for not being sufficiently scary while blaming it for being scary.
The only interesting development seems to be the methodology but that only gets a passing mention.
The rest is basically fearmongering.
> In humans, for example, gut bacteria influence how the immune system responds to pathogens and allergens, or interact with the brain, affecting mood.
Ok. But what does that have to do with diversity? Humans have not been an emotionally rational species at any point in the past. Arguably the relationship between gut biome diversity and civilization is inverse. Maybe we want fewer microbes.
Lifespan has also increased with decreased gut biome diversity.
This is why correlation alone is uninteresting. You can find it anywhere.
> Splitting the difference, people in less developed parts of the world have between 60 and 65 of those bacterial groups, an observation that ties the decrease in microbial diversity to urbanization.
Oh come on. How does a line like this get published? This is fine if you define “ties” as “moves with” but not “is connected to”. IOW correlation doesn’t imply causation.
> Kyle Meyer, a microbiologist at UC Berkeley, argues such losses are not necessarily a problem. “Maybe we don’t need them,” he points out. But Moeller is worried. “We are really doing some scary stuff to our microbiomes,” he warns.
Why is it “scary”? Nothing in this article established any cause for concern.
The guy that developed the methodology is now in search of a problem his solution fits.