Re:SEC rejects Grayscale Bitcoin ETF application [pdf]
by toolz on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:15PM
(#31928074)
You can buy ETFs for all sorts of commodities, currencies and securities. No matter which umbrella bitcoin falls under, there are numerous etfs that can be be compared, right? Why is bitcoin or crypto special here? Is it the SECs job to make judgements on the assets that want to be included in the exchange?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:SEC rejects Grayscale Bitcoin ETF application [pdf]
by steveBK123 on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:26PM
(#31928139)
Spot commodity linked ETNs have well regulated custodians physically holding assets in vaults.
SEC probably has concerns about Grayscales ability to securely hold custody of bitcoin. Given "All my apes gone" and other recent debacles, this isn't too surprising.
Re:SEC rejects Grayscale Bitcoin ETF application [pdf]
by woodruffw on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:20PM
(#31928106)
> Is it the SECs job to make judgements on the assets that want to be included in the exchange?
Yes, and that is the crux of the argument: the Exchange Act requires the SEC to evaluate ETPs for the possibility of "fraudulent and manipulative acts and practices." In other words: the SEC lacks confidence that approving a spot ETF for Bitcoin would not further advance manipulation and/or fraudulent behavior in the Bitcoin market.
Re:SEC rejects Grayscale Bitcoin ETF application [pdf]
by toolz on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:23PM
(#31928123)
No, it's their job to protect consumers. It is not their responsibility to make moral judgements on assets.
Re:SEC rejects Grayscale Bitcoin ETF application [pdf]
by woodruffw on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @10:25PM
(#31928130)
There is no moral judgment here. "Fraudulent and manipulative acts and practices" is the language of systemic and individual risk, not a moral statement.
(You will note that the SEC is more than happy to allow ETFs that specialize in petrochemicals or defense contractors; there is no evidence whatsoever that this was a morally driven decision.)
Re:SEC rejects Grayscale Bitcoin ETF application [pdf]
by davidgerard on Thursday June 30, 2022 @07:06AM
(#31930927)
They've repeatedly set out the problems with the bitcoin market that make it unsuitable for an ETF, responding to ETF applications over the past two years.
Every new ETF application has just blithely ignored the previous reasons for refusal, and Grayscale ignored them too.
At this point, the blockchain industry is just playing dumb and pretending not to understand.