The SEC's response here is actually very even handed: they agree that there are advantages to a spot ETF for Bitcoin on a regulated exchange. The ruling observes that the presence of advantages is not sufficient: there must be proof that the rule change would not enable "fraudulent and manipulative acts and practices." They've also laid out how that proof might be obtained in the future: through a "surveillance-sharing agreement" that ensures transparency concerning the underlying assets.
This is law, not an undergraduate philosophy of logic class. "Proof" in these contexts means providing supporting or contradictory evidence; the SEC is stating that a company that wishes to offer a spot Bitcoin ETF must provide sufficient evidence that contradicts the other evidence that Bitcoin's market is susceptible to fraud and manipulation.
Edit: The SEC lays out some of this evidence on pages 22ff.
The SEC is gatekeeping one specific market.
Right. That’s the point. Indictments and settlements.
Meanwhile, we know e.g. Tether and its affiliates lied materially, they said as much to the New York DA. Yet no enforcement action. No oversight.
The SEC is gatekeeping this specific market based on an accidental and optional administrative purview that should be corrected.
Thus - the game of spot ETF.
Grayscale isn’t rushing either, because they are farming management fees.
Only ones losing is “investors”. The ones that the SEC suppose to protect.