Thankfully that's why the article first gave the metric in tons of carbon, which has no such ambiguity.
> So why are we not just using the geothermal energy powering this thing to charge electric vehicles or power homes?
My understanding is that there is generally an over supply of renewable energy in Iceland. Historically it attracted location agnostic consumers like aluminum smelting and bitcoin mining as consumers of this energy, because there wasn't any other demand for the renewable energy in Iceland.
Not so quick. Does a layman have any reference point to what is considered "a lot" of carbon? Is there a way to readily measure my vehicle and see what it produces? No... and the article even attempts to provide some sort of "scale" metric, and only succeeds in making this DAC seem underwhelmingly useless, less than a drop in the bucket.
> My understanding is that there is generally an over supply of renewable energy in Iceland.
That may be so, but this still doesn't make this a good use of that surplus.
I don't think a comparison to another producer of carbon would actually help a layman. Whether that is a lot or not would depend on the cost and energy used by the plant itself, which isn't really given in this article.
> That may be so, but this still doesn't make this a good use of that surplus.
Why? Suppose there is no other demand for that energy. What is actually wasted in that case? How do you measure what is "good"?
Or work on ways to "package" the produced energy and export it to other nations efficiently.
Regardless, this DAC is consuming lots of energy and producing very little (if any, likely no) benefit at all, and in the process of merely being brought into existence releases a lot of emissions. It would quite literally be better to not even build it in the first place it seems... given the lofty-but-insignificant numbers the article provides.
You have to quantify these things in some way, otherwise you are making purely subjective claims. I don't think this project does a good job of using data to quantify that it is useful, but it is even less legitimate to dismiss it in the same way. How do you measure that a Data Center would be a better use of this power? How would a prototype of a project that "packages" energy for transport also not just be perceived as a total waste of effort?
Because the technology there doesn't rely on literally sucking all of the atmosphere through a machine to achieve some sort of positive effect.
We can do napkin math and conclude already this machine achieves nearly no results - and worse, it took over a decade to achieve nearly no results - and even worse, to scale this thing to a level where it does actually register some sort of impact is unachievable.
Again... doing the wrong thing is often worse than doing nothing at all. This machine, and all DAC's like it are a complete waste of time and resources.
The only atmosphere being cleaned is that which passes through the machine. It's like a hepa filter for your house. Place the filter in a clean room, and it'll still work, but it'll take an exceedingly long period of time to circulate all the air in your home. The real-world atmosphere isn't stagnant like that in your home either... with currents and what-not, meaning this machine needs to be all over the globe to make meaningful impact.
> I challenge you to actually do the napkin math here, rather than continue to state your claim that it achieves "nearly no results" without anything quantifying what that means.
Others in this thread have already done so. But here it goes again:
Total estimated global CO2 emissions (according to the article) are 36,000,000,000 tons per year. This machine is advertised to extract 36,000 tons per year (which likely means less since this is clearly a puff piece, but we'll use this number anyway).
This is 1/1,000,000th of global CO2 emissions - meaning we'd need 1,000,000 more identical machines to achieve CO2 neutrality - which assumes zero net increase in emissions over whatever period of time it takes to manufacture and install all of these machines (which isn't reality).
We don't know the emission cost of producing these machines - but it certainly isn't zero. We also don't know the emission cost of the energy being produced to power these things (which even with geo-thermal, is not zero either).
We also don't know how large the footprint of these machines are - but given the rendering they do look to be huge.
Lastly, we still don't know if it's a good idea to just deposit possibly billions of tons of carbon into the earth every year anyway, making this contraption more of a fantasy than something productive.
This is like saying that the only gasoline that is consumed is that which is burned up in a car. 1) A car can still be useful without consuming all gasoline in the world. This machine could be economically viable given carbon credit structures as well, it doesn't have to scale to solve the problem on its own, it just has to be efficient enough to be worth building (I'm not claiming that it meets this criteria). 2) Clearly we could actually use up the majority of gasoline on earth, there is no reason why scaling something that much is impossible.
> with currents and what-not, meaning this machine needs to be all over the globe to make meaningful impact.
Are you really saying this is an obstacle-- that if we wanted to make 1 million of these machines we would be unable to distribute them, and that furthermore we would completely clean the co2 from the atmosphere over a single country before the currents and what-not would bring in more co2 for the machines to consume? If this is true, then why do we care about co2 emissions in other countries currently?
> We don't know the emission cost of producing these machines - but it certainly isn't zero. We also don't know the emission cost of the energy being produced to power these things (which even with geo-thermal, is not zero either).
I agree that we need to know this and the other factors and that they are larger than zero, but it is critically important to know the actual values, or at least a rough estimate. How are you so confident whether it would work or not without knowing them, or even giving an estimate and doing the napkin math?
Cars burning gasoline is a side effect. This machine cleaning the atmosphere is its entire purpose.
What we have here is a "Carbon Rush" and everyone who gets in early will get rich but likely end up accomplishing nothing (or make things worse in unforeseeable ways).
Sorry to be so blunt, but the numbers and schemes that come out of these things are woefully unrealistic.
In addition, none of these schemes make any difference so long as developing nations (and some developed nations) continue to produce emissions at staggering rates. All the efforts here are wasted if, say China, builds even one new coal plant.
So, a best guess at a solution is to stop wasting time trying to extract and hide emissions, and instead work to further pursue technology that produces less emissions from the start. Manufacturing would be a great place to start, because even this DAC machine is going to produce a massive amount of emissions during production... all the way down to the trucks mining the raw materials for the forge.
But those are hard, difficult problems to solve... and aren't "sexy", which denies quick VC money and grants.
These solutions require deep industry knowledge and buy-in, deep understanding of the problem space, and deep pockets to front unproven technology that nobody will adopt until it solves their problems better than the current solutions.
ie. you are not going to revolutionize mining just because you want it to be more green. It doesn't matter how much money have, and how many domain-novices you employ. The mining/farming/manufacturing/whatever industry will not even entertain your product unless it's objectively better.
No industry actually cares about being more environmentally friendly at the trade off of reduced production and efficiency, or increased costs - all things that come along with unproven technology developed by people that had little-to-zero understanding of that industry's problems in the first place.
I'm really worried we have no idea what we're doing, and will find out down the road things like this only made things worse, or caused other unforeseen problems.
I do not subscribe to the philosophy that "doing something is better than nothing", particularly when we likely don't fully understand what it is we're doing or actually trying to achieve. Doing the wrong thing can be, and often is, worse than doing nothing.
> Orca can capture about 4,000 tons of carbon per year (for scale, that’s equal to the annual emissions of 790 cars).
That's some hand-wavy numbers there. 790 of what type of car? 1970 muscle car without a catalytic converter and modern fuel injection system? Or a 2022 Prius? One outputs a huge amount of CO2 and other gases, and the other hardly any at all.
Car emissions are really good on average. As technology progresses, it might be fathomable that 7,900 cars, or eventually 79,000 cars produce the same amount of emissions as today. This "metric" sounds impressive, but it's useless.
> DAC’s energy usage, particularly when it’s considered in conjunction with the (relatively minuscule) amount of CO2 it’s capturing, is its biggest drawback. Sourcing the energy from renewable sources helps, but it’s still not unlimited nor free.
So why are we not just using the geothermal energy powering this thing to charge electric vehicles or power homes?
> Meanwhile, global emissions topped 36 billion tons last year. 36,000 tons (the quantity of CO2 that will be captured by the Mammoth facility) is a negligible fraction of that total. Is it even worth the energy usage, construction and maintenance costs, and frankly, the effort? Or would the geothermally-generated electricity go to better use powering electric cars?
Ah, they even mention this in the article. Of course the CEO hand waves this away...
I'm not convinced this is the future - seems more like a get rich quick scheme if anything. Sort of like those companies you can pay to "offload" your emission burden and supposedly they plant trees or something and you get to claim your carbon neutral. Scams... all of them.