News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cancelling Student Debt Is Unforgivable by eesmith on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @08:13AM (#31919065)
> and those that granted them with the belief that they will get the money back at some point

Most people who loan money factor in the chance that the money won't be paid back, for example, if the person who took out the loan files for bankruptcy.

Student loans, however, are much harder to discharge than other loans. (See https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/student-loan-debt-ba... for how the process works.)

What the state can do is get let student loans be dischargable as normal consumer debt, just like it once was.

This opinion piece titled "Don't Cancel Student Loans. Let Bankruptcy Law Forgive Them" at https://www.newsweek.com/dont-cancel-student-loans-let-bankr... is one of many pieces arguing for that change to bankruptcy law.

Re:Cancelling Student Debt Is Unforgivable by XorNot on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @08:32AM (#31919257)
The reason this isn't done is because the obvious play is for a student with no assets to take the loans, get a degree, declare bankruptcy, and cruise out the next 7 years with a better paying job - it's not like they'll be ready to afford anything they'd need financing for anyway.

The problem of course is that the fix flips it the other way: student loan debt is functionally the safest possible debt because it can't be discharged through bankruptcy. Loan someone any amount of money, and provided you estimate their net productivity over their life accurately, you'll get your money back.

In isolation all of this sounds somewhat justifiable, but in the real world the results are disastrous: students are gate kept from higher income by getting a degree in a serious way, so they take on this undischargeable debt which people are happy to keep lending, so there's never any counter-pressure to colleges raising tuition rates, and government can say "everything is fine! Look at these enrollment numbers not changing!"

Re:Cancelling Student Debt Is Unforgivable by eesmith on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @09:30AM (#31919847)
In 1976 the law was changed to require 5 years until student loans could be discharged through bankruptcy. In 1990 it became 7 years. In 1998 the waiting period was eliminated, leaving only "undue hardship" as the allowed way to get rid of that debt.

Those waiting periods were put there as a counter to "the obvious play."

Let student loans be dischargable through normal bankruptcy again. If a waiting period of 5 years or 7 years isn't enough, why not?

Why is a potential life-long debt from a mistake made while still a teenager or in one's early 20s that important to maintain?

If it's still so risky, don't issue student loans! If a college education is so important to the country then the government can provide direct funding to the school and students.

> you'll get your money back

Plus interest, with earnings that exceed putting the same money into other investments.

Re:Cancelling Student Debt Is Unforgivable by lotsofpulp on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @09:11AM (#31919608)
> In isolation all of this sounds somewhat justifiable

The government lending money via blank checks as long as a person is enrolled in an “accredited” school was never justifiable.

Except to voters who wanted lower taxes now and the politician who could deliver those lower taxes by reducing cash spending on higher education facilities and instead lending to students which can then be booked as an asset on the government’s books.

Re:Cancelling Student Debt Is Unforgivable by raxxorraxor on Wednesday June 29, 2022 @09:09AM (#31919589)
Framed this way it seems to be a very safe capital investment that also provides student ownership.