>What's wrong with it?
it excludes people who would live there but the zoning doesn't allow it.
On the scale of a single town this doesn't matter, but on the scale of an entire metro area all these little zoning groups make it impossible to anything anywhere in the entire area and so it destroys the whole. zoning is good for any one small area, but across the entire metro area the sum total is bad.
Let me be cynical: so what? They'll go and live elsewhere.
> it destroys the whole.
There is a huge difference between slowing the growth (or even stopping the growth) and destroying a city.
A usual problem with successful cities is they attract more people, which attract more business, which attract more people and so on. It's time we learn how to keep the economy in good health without our cities turning to anthills.
What is you get San Franciso where you cannot find enough people who can afford to work in your city to take care of the basic jobs.
> zoning is controlled almost exclusively by local city councils
What's wrong with it?
People opposing the status quo usually look to imply that every citizen of the USA should have the right to go and live where he likes the most, at the price and at the conditions it prefers.
Why should I be able to force, for example, San Francisco to build cheap homes for me to move there? If I can't afford San Francisco, I'll go live elsewhere.
Instead, if I live in San Francisco, I will participate in the local political life and vote according to my preferences.