Competition is a good thing whether in labor or oil or chicken markets.
A cartel is a set of profit seeking firms in a specific industry who hold enough market influence to dictate price. It is the coordinated actions of an oligopoly to manipulate the market. You don't need to own the full market, you just need to be able to influence the market as a whole.
A union is, on a very surface level similar to a cartel, but unions are monopolies of labor, and do not represent the firms themselves.
They are both attempts to manipulate markets through group decision making, but even academically, they aren't seen as the same thing. There is a reason that cartel formation is very illegal while union formation is a protected right.
that's like saying OPEC isn't a cartel because you can still get oil from russia or canada.
>it can fire it's entire workforce and rehire
isn't that union-busting and/or illegal?
> isn't that union-busting and/or illegal?
It's supposed to be, but it's often the case that corporations are not penalized to a sufficient amount (or at all) to deter this. We've seen many cases where it's cheaper for the corporation to pay these fines and continue doing what they are doing - in that sense the current laws are ineffective.
On a local level? Maybe? But consider that the US workers of the most valuable car company in the world (by a factor of about 3)are not part of the UAW, so it's debatable at best.
It's not even in the top 10 of car manufacturers by revenue. In fact it's only like 1/5th the size of the tenth place (Hyundai), or about 1/14th the size of the first place on that list (Volkswagen). It's not going move any car markets on its own, regardless of what goes on at Tesla.
So yeah, valuation is completely detached from (current) reality in this case, and Tesla is not a great example.
We could look at the biggest manufacturer instead, but I'm sure most people have heard of VW's union by now.
In fact this is why the Clayton Act specifically exempts unions from anti-trust law, and it's why "Right to work" laws are so controversial - they reduce the monopoly status of the union.
Correct me, if I'm understanding but your point seems to be this
Unions are a monopoly so it makes sense to call OPEC a union.
Let me refer us both back to intro to programming and frame this in OOP terms. Just because a Cat has an IS-A relationship to Animal, does not make all Animals Cats.
> OPEC is also a union
missedthecue 1 hour ago
> I wouldn't call OPEC a union
You might want to re-examine your cybersecurity measures - someone hacked your account.
We're really just splitting hairs at this point. My main point is that the motives and tactics of both OPEC and the UAW are identical.
aka collective bargaining.
> If you willingly compete
aka defecting.
It's just game theory. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Logic_of_Collective_Action I really don't understand why people get so fluffed up about it.
However, first, many workplace safety rules were promulgated by govt commissions formed in response to specific events. They could be established via a one-time campaign, without a permanent institution like unions... just like many other safety and other standards - we don't have an all-encompassing seatbelt-union or anti-smoking union or low-car-exhaust union, just one-time campaign followed by a pointed intervention. Even such easier-to-violate, more nebulous policies as 40-hour work week generally persisted, and spread around the world, despite decline in unionization.
Additionally, salary and working conditions for many occupations (e.g. software) are great based purely on market forces, without unions. It's not a given that most of the good impact of unions wouldn't have happened without them.
But again, sure, I did grant some credit to unions for that. However, one may also grant nukes some credit in saving many lives by ending WWII early, and yet not be pro-nuke.
Why do you choose to judge unions on that one episode, and not many of their negative impacts?
Sure, let me post them again with links to some sources.
1) Union racism - I thought there was even a congressional testimony by a union leader against allowing Blacks moving to the North to take jobs, but I cannot find it now. However, while I thought it was a 1950-ies problem - [1, including describing a system that goes beyond personal prejudice; etc.], while researching, I found it may STILL be a problem! [2]
2) Union-mafia connections [3, etc. - well known]
3) Anti-immigration stance of unions [4], incl. e.g. famously Cesar Chavez using union power to help deport undocumented immigrants via both law and with violence [5]
4) UAW role in destruction of American auto industry. This one is really typical, the union was milking a recently over-concentrated auto industry when the rest of the world had no auto industry to speak of. At the first sight of competition the whole thing collapsed. [6]
5) Unions preventing and protesting automation of ports, and successfully preventing the govt funding of it during a supply crunch [7] [8]
6) Generalized corruption. Too many small examples, here's a recent one in UAW [9]
7) Featherbedding. Similarly, many examples, some I know personally, NY infrastructure is the most prominent [10]
8) AMA limiting residency spots, med school accreditation, hospital certificates of need, etc. => limiting physicians per capital, producing more expensive healthcare.
9) Police unions... need I say more?
With a cursory search you can find much more in each category, and probably more categories too.
Why would you expect anything else? Think about a union from the first principles, it's as if someone wanted to make a basket case for every possible misaligned incentive.
* Unions have ultimate, NIMBY-like rent-seeking incentive, based on restriction and exclusion of other labor (as demonstrated above, up to racism and anti-immigrant violence when viable - but also via certification beyond any practical necessity, etc.). In a market labor would get wages it deserves. Union incentive is to milk a company for as much extra as it can instead AND ALSO to exclude other labor.
The bet is that even if the company dies, workers will just go to the next one. Or the company can continue as a zombie, with union maneuvering to get as much of the spoils as possible. Sometimes it doesn't work, as with Detroit where it didn't work and industry went abroad; notably, the key union achievements were at the time where the "abroad" was undeveloped and/or bombed out.
Public sector unions are an ultimate racket here, as public sector cannot really go under (I hope) so it can be rent-seeked-from forever.
* They have nothing to gain from progress or innovation that may eliminate jobs or make them more efficient (hence fighting port automation, or at least making automation useless by featherbedding like in NYC).
* They generally are monopolistic, but instead of being broken up/regulated/at least frowned upon like many monopolistic companies, their monopolies and/or coordination with each other is encourage.
* If those weren't enough, long-term, they have basically unaccountable leaders operating over a base of people who, rightfully, are not very engaged in the union politics. Perfect breeding ground for corruption, especially combined with the above two - you cannot run most companies with incompetents and mafia members, you will run them into the ground; but you can easily run a union.
Aside from gangs/mobs/cartels/armies/etc., unions are truly the most harmful institution even created by man. If I wanted to invent an institution with worse incentives from scratch I couldn't have come up with anything so bad.
[1] https://www.commentary.org/articles/herbert-hill/labor-union... [2] https://ssir.org/articles/entry/union_constructions_racial_e... [3] https://www.justice.gov/criminal-ocgs/infiltrated-labor-unio... [4] https://www.npr.org/2013/02/05/171175054/how-the-labor-movem... [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cesar_Chavez#cite_ref-FOOTNOTE... [6] https://cei.org/blog/empire-of-rust-how-the-uaw-killed-detro... [7] https://www.porttechnology.org/news/west-coast-ports-and-uni... [8] https://reason.com/2021/11/09/americas-ports-need-more-robot... [9] https://www.denverpost.com/2021/06/10/united-auto-workers-ga... [10] https://tunnelingonline.com/why-tunnels-in-the-us-cost-much-....
2 things I learned from participating in the comments to this post so far:
1) unions are even more awful than I originally thought.
2) when I tried arguing with hardcore creationists in the aughtts, I thought that they must be the most dishonest and incompetent interlocutors in history; I was wrong - that was before I met union activists :D now that I think of it, it makes sense, Earth being 5kyo does sound more believable than unions doing good :P
That is to say, all the libertarians complaining about unions and vaccines can do so comfortably only because they have never been exposed to the horrors they helped to prevent .