News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by andrepd on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:17AM (#31893474)
Could you please elaborate in what way exactly the union "binds you to lowest performing co-worker"? As it stands your accusation is both vague and a classic anti-union scaremongering buzzword.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by NikolaNovak on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:40AM (#31893715)
No the op, but as I've mentioned before:

1. I 100% support unions in general and in principle; and 100% support their causes

2. All (every.single.one) unions I've actually personally seen or experienced, in North America, in real life, absolutely were about lowest common denominator.

All unions I've witnessed were solely about seniority. Merit, hard work, initiative, skills, etc were simply not in the contract / not relevant / not a consideration in any sense. Best performing / hardest working, and worst performing person are paid exactly the same, if they are at the same seniority level. So in the most obvious sense you tie yourself to the lowest performing worker. I have literally, literally seen a person competent to operate a machine, replaced by union with a person not trained to operate machine, because of seniority. It was something out of Kafkian Monty Python but it happens frequently.

All unions I've witnessed spent majority of their time, energy and credit fighting for the lowest performing worker. And not in the emotional movie starring Will Smith poor downtrodden worker. No, I mean poop on the factory floor, come to work drunk, then not come to work, then lather rinse repeat, for months. And I mean every one of those words literally, and no it was not a "friend of a cousin of a brother of a guy". It is extremely damaging for the morale of any good worker, and for the relationship with management/business, when union behaves like that. You don't feel like they're a partner, you don't feel they have your best interests in mind.

The slightly more office oriented unions I've witnessed were still suicidal, in the sense that they never ever ever looked at business and the market; they'll strike for a month to get them something that'll close the business in a year.

So, I fully understand that I am lucky, privileged, and have the absolute luxury to not need a union right now. I fully understand that may change and I may be having short sighted perspectives. I firmly believe unions can be a necessary force for good. I fully agree that if you're in a Amazon warehouse today, you probably darn tootin' well want to be unionized.

But I also fully understand how somebody might not be 100% ready to sign "Yes" even without fear mongering and propaganda and bullying, i.e. for legitimate personal and general reasons. In my mind it's still a different kind of propaganda / blindness to believe that every vote for No is because of intimidation (and let's not forget unions can and do intimidate in their own way. Try to cross a striking line or fight for meritocracy or against seniority or not toe the union line and see how long the smiles last. It's ultimately just another kind of bureaucracy / social institution with its own life and rules). Not everybody who wants to have a meaningful discussion and present/is aware of multiple sides to an issue, is "classic anti-union scaremongering".

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by treeman79 on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:51AM (#31893869)
Talking to many people who have been in or around unions for decades. Low performance seems to be the goal.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by Jhjjjjjjjj on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:37AM (#31893688)
The lowest performing worker gets paid the same as a high performing one. Not very difficult to understand his point
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by andrepd on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:46AM (#31894539)
How does collective bargaining imply uniformisation of pay? I still don't see the connection.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by hourago on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:28AM (#31893587)
Propaganda seems to work, then.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by viraptor on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:14AM (#31893447)
Both the highest and lowest performing co-worker have some shared needs and goals. The article mentions a few of them (for example toilet break time and respecting safety protocols). Keep in mind that the highest performing person is one minor injury away from being below average for a very long time.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by jmyeet on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:50AM (#31893856)
I'll highlight that the scope of my comment was deliberate, precise and narrow. The broader issue of unionization brings in other factors but we're talking about Amazon warehouse workers here.

These workers by their nature are highly replaceable. Replacebility is built into the system. It's desirable for the company. It's horrible for people and completely unnecessary.

What are you? Some star performer who can pack the boxes 10x better than the next guy? That's not a thing.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by dementiapatie on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:47AM (#31894548)
There are definitely 0.1x box packers, and I claim to be at least 1x. I don't want them on my team or in my union!
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by hourago on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:27AM (#31893576)
Are you better negotiating alone against a big corporation? It seems that you are overestimating your personal bargain power. (And maybe overestimating your own ability)
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by arsome on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:26AM (#31893566)
This. After my experiences at a union shop, I would never vote to unionize, seems to serve only to keep useless people around with management having to play hot potato with them as they're too hard to get rid of. Oh and as a bonus you get to pay for wasting half your day on useless people.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by UncleMeat on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:51AM (#31893874)
A union is just democratic control over the workplace. Your options are zero control or a small amount of control via voting.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by raverbashing on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:42AM (#31893754)
Yes, feel free to push hard packing things for Bezos, I'm sure you'll be treated well with an extra minute to go to the toilet or 100 amzn-bucks bonus

Just make sure you don't underperform for any important length of time, either by fatigue, injury or any other reason.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by djrobstep on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:32AM (#31893642)
Interesting phenomenon I’ve noticed: Any thread on HN related to unions soon gets newly created accounts arriving to spread anti-union FUD talking points.
Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by NikolaNovak on Monday June 27, 2022 @08:46AM (#31893813)
Right; It's not because anybody in any forum bringing up any dissenting points, immediately gets downvoted and called (and I quote from this thread) "classic anti-union scaremongering propagandist shill" and worse. No, it is definitely an anti-union conspiracy, and we are all definitely willing to discuss all sides of a contentious issue. /s

For what it's worth, I've been on Hacker News for many years, and it is against my better judgment to comment on this topic with my ID and name. Just look in this thread to the one-line reaction posts; turn on the "see dead posts" and check out how quickly opposing opinions are downvoted and flagged; and put yourself in position of anybody having even a slightly dissenting opinion or wanting to present both sides of an issue or a different, personal perspective. HN can be brutal.

Re:Amazon is intimidating and harassing organizing workers i... by phil21 on Monday June 27, 2022 @09:00AM (#31893964)
The interesting phenomenon I've noticed on HN are folks who have never worked a labor job in their life pontificating on how unions operate in the real world.

It makes you really wonder about the other decisions being made for society by this group of folks who have outsize power at the moment.