That alone makes it better than the native iPhone Mail application for me, since now I'm not going to get automated messages, newsgroup messages, etc., in my phone's main inbox.
So far I'm quite happy with it (I noticed the error on initial launch but ignored it - stupid mistake for Google to make, but didn't seem to affect my use of the application) and I'm kind of relieved it doesn't have push notifications, since I'm not sure I want them unless I can turn them off. Not so sure why everyone is piling on so hard.
I don't know the current situation, but for example Nitro was not available on UIWebView in iOS 4.3 ; also UIWebView does not do any caching by itself and doing it yourself is tricky. So this may explain why the performance of this GMail app is worse than the web app.
I understand why one would release native apps with web UIs. It's totally fine if you're on a budget. But the iPhone already has a perfectly fine email app and it also syncs well with your Google Apps account through its Exchange integration.
If an official GMail app is not better than the built-in functionality, then it's not only useless, but also affects their credibility.
Isn't Apple destroying their brand with the original iPhone 4's crappy antenna and with the new iPhone 4's crappy battery life?
Bugs happen. It's software.
The OP isn't complaining about this bug. He's complaining of what appears to be a systemic problem both technically and in product design with Googles iOS apps. These issues can't just be hand waved away as easily as "It's software"
Bugs happen, always. And, of course, there are compromises you have to make to product, always, in order to ship.
What matters is where you draw the line. I'm sure that nobody will say that the antenna problem 'ruined' the iPhone. After all, it still launched, people still bought it, and all was well.
Three times now, for some reason, Google has * completely* ruined their launches. The Google Voice app, the Google+ app, and the GMail app all had easily caught, gamebreaking bugs that were so major that they required a full recall of the app.
For a tiny startup, this sort of launch-fumbling would be pretty bad. For an enormous company, it's almost laughable.
Every new iPhone I've bought -- and I've owned them all except the 3G -- has run down quickly the first couple of times I charged it, and every one has eventually achieved reasonable battery life after the break-in period. The 4S was no exception. Non-story, move on. It's unclear why Apple doesn't explain this.
I did discover one such issue. I have the New York Times app and access to a subscription for it. After updating to iOS5, the first time I tried to use the NYT app, it moved itself into the new "Newsstand" and changed its behavior so I started getting "alerts" whenever anything allegedly newsworthy happened. I had never gotten such alerts before, because I had that feature turned off. It was ridiculously hard to find the option to entirely turn off unattended polling related to the NYT app because the setting isn't where you'd expect it to be. (It's in Settings:Store)
(Apple has apparently identified some of the issues and just started beta-testing an update that is alleged to fix them.)
It's not about whether Apple writes better iOS apps than Google does for Android, it's about whether Google makes any good apps for iOS.
In contrast, Android's gmail client is one of Android's biggest draws, and has never in my two years of using Android had a bad release. Instead it just keeps getting better.
In particular, it often blocked the main (UI) thread while waiting for data from the network, so it would hang for seconds at a time. Not doing that is pretty much application development 101.
1. No one has taken time to address the real issue—yes, there's a weird bug on launch, but the real issue is that the app itself blows. It's terrible. It's basically entirely a web view that runs even slower than the GMail webapp itself. As Scoble says in the comments: "The bar is high for apps. Make it better than a web page or DO NOT RELEASE! Please."
2. This an absurdly easy thing to check for. This has happened first with the Google Voice app, then with the Google+ app, now with the GMail app. Is Google committed to systematically destroying their own brand?