News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by jaclaz on Sunday June 26, 2022 @04:29AM (#31882121)
The article is actually about underpasses, which are not "tunnels" but rather a bridge (or overpass) built on the "other" road.

Such "tunnels" are normally very short and straight, so I cannot understand the reference to turns in the article, a "real" tunnel is several tens of meters, more often hundreds or thousands meters long and very likely is not straight, though I doubt that they are the preferred hideout for mugglers aiming at cyclists.

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by nstom on Sunday June 26, 2022 @05:11AM (#31882302)
Based on his name and the picture in the article, I assume the author is Dutch. We don’t have the distinction between underpasses and tunnels in our language and just call everything ‘tunnel’. It may have to do with the country being so flat that there are no mountains to tunnel through.

I can only think of a single real bicycle/pedestrian tunnel, which is the Maastunnel in Rotterdam. Incidentally it is also one of the oldest tunnels in the country. It was recently renovated and is actually really pleasant to cycle through, because motorised traffic uses a separate tunnel tube.

As for turns in underpasses, at complex junctions or infrastructural elements it may be tempting to just make a small bend so that the underpass is cheaper to build or easier to fit in to the environment. Take these crossroads for example: https://goo.gl/maps/21Yqj89WwyiiuZfD9. If you look closely you will see a bicycle tunnel going underneath from the southwest to the northeast. This important connection for the residents southwest of the shopping center is relatively long and has a slight bend. This makes it feel dark and unsafe to the people who use it.

A better design can be found at this roundabout: https://goo.gl/maps/TXuFjXj85huufc7m6. Because the middle section is open, all of the individual underpasses are short and there is a lot of daylight, making cycling there safer and more pleasant.

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by jaclaz on Sunday June 26, 2022 @06:03AM (#31882529)
Yep, I understand that now.

Here in Italy (where we have lots of mountains and conversely tunnels) the distiction between tunnel and underpass (or overpass) is neat, we also have (though not extremely common) distinctions betweeen different kinds of tunnels (Galleria):

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by LittlePeter on Sunday June 26, 2022 @05:52AM (#31882477)
There is "onderdoorgang", which shows similar images as in the OP: https://www.google.com/search?q=onderdoorgang

But I don't think I ever used this word... I'd say tunnel I guess.

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by Beldin on Sunday June 26, 2022 @08:37AM (#31883366)
Overpass is called "viaduct" in Dutch, though a multi-lane overpass is often colloquially called a tunnel. We do have tunnel-like structures for what technically are overpasses, eg.: bike path next to a river; major multilane road crosses river+bikepath; resulting structure for bike path is a tunnel (Dommeltunneltje in Eindhoven), though doesn't go underground.
Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by bobthepanda on Sunday June 26, 2022 @04:45AM (#31882172)
Actual tunnels are usually pretty awful for cyclists, pedestrians and motorcyclists since they tend to be hot and full of exhaust fumes.
Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by sofixa on Sunday June 26, 2022 @05:58AM (#31882496)
Not if the tunnel is cycle and pedestrian only, like the Sint Anna tunnel under the Scheldt in Antwerp.
Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by robinson7d on Sunday June 26, 2022 @11:56AM (#31885080)
Totally, and this seems to be exactly the type of tunnel that the article’s author is discussing, evidenced by the second point they make:

> Tunnels have a smaller height difference than bridges. Only need clearance for the height of a cyclist, not for trucks or trains plus electric lines.

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by bobthepanda on Sunday June 26, 2022 @04:26PM (#31887614)
Note the phrasing of "actual tunnel", which is meant to agree with this in the comment chain

> The article is actually about underpasses, which are not "tunnels" but rather a bridge (or overpass) built on the "other" road.

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by AlecSchueler on Sunday June 26, 2022 @04:52AM (#31882212)
Any tunnel I've been in has been fine. Motorcycles can't enter, they have to go on the road, not the cycle lane. Smaller "scooters" can be admitted but there is plenty of active ventilation to deal with that.

In the case of the Maas Tunnel in Rotterdam there is a second tunnel for combustion vehicles. Pedestrians have a tunnel of their own below the cycle tunnel.

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by seszett on Sunday June 26, 2022 @05:02AM (#31882266)
The Kennedytunnel in Antwerp is two-level with a bike tunnel on top of the (very crowded) motorway, and it does smell of fumes in spite of the ventilation.

The large detours of the bike path at both ends of the tunnel are also a bit annoying as they significantly increase the distance you have to cycle. The alternative with elevators like in the Sint Annatunnel isn't really better though, because there you just have to wait for a long time for the elevator.

I much prefer bridges but where I've used bike bridges (like in Nantes) they were very low with little clearance above water. Even in Lille they're just a few meters, maybe ten meters at most, above water, so they're easy to climb without a large detour.

I wouldn't take the Pont de Cheviré on a bike for example...

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by agsnu on Sunday June 26, 2022 @05:59AM (#31882501)
I immediately thought of the Rotherhithe tunnel in London. While pedestrians and cyclists can use it, it's grim - see this video for example of someone walking it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hjAHzZa_pc8

Clearly for crossing any lengthy stretch of water, a bridge is much preferable to a tunnel.

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by AlecSchueler on Sunday June 26, 2022 @10:05AM (#31884119)
You're basing that position of the case of one badly designed bridge though. Try some underwater cycling tunnels in the Netherlands. The Benelux tunnel is a joy to use.
Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by AlecSchueler on Monday June 27, 2022 @12:22PM (#31896808)
Tunnel* not bridge
Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by vinay427 on Sunday June 26, 2022 @05:01AM (#31882260)
I think they meant tunnels in general that affect people not in cars, including motorcyclists, because of their lack of a loosely airtight or climate-controlled environment. As opposed to a tunnel specifically for bicyclists and motorcyclists, which is also how I read it at first.
Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by Gualdrapo on Sunday June 26, 2022 @05:11AM (#31882301)
And (at least here in Bogotá) they are pretty good places for burglars to hide, surprise and attack cyclists.
Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by rmbyrro on Sunday June 26, 2022 @05:12AM (#31882314)
Clarification: this is valid, useful criticism, not at all pendantry.

Usage of the "tunnels" word got me confused through the first half of the article, until it showed a photo of an underpassage in the Netherlands.

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by anttiharju on Sunday June 26, 2022 @04:35AM (#31882141)
Yeah, underpass is a much more appropriate name.

Now that you mention it, it does seem strange that the article doesn't mention turns before/after tunnels as those tend to lead to risk taking (going too fast into the underpass that you can't see into).

At least in Finland the underpasses used by cyclists are also used by pedestrians, so the underpasses being used as mugging spots is conceivable, although I've never heard about it happening.

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by Someone on Sunday June 26, 2022 @06:31AM (#31882634)
I think it’s more about perceived safety than about actual risks.

A design that is safe, but makes “the people” think it is dangerous is a failed design, as fewer people would use it.

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by emn13 on Sunday June 26, 2022 @10:29AM (#31884337)
I live near a mixed use cycle+pedestrian underpass under a railroad that has curves into and out of it. It's mildy terrifying in a way that's surely by design. I don't know how safe it actually is, but it _is_ used very heavily - because it's by far the shortest path connecting most routes on the opposite sides of the train track, which trumps virtually all other concerns in day to day traffic, especially for pedestrians and cyclists.

And hey, there's no car traffic, so accidents are likely to be at least a little milder, though hitting one of those stone pillars is perhaps not much better.

Re:Cycling: Why Tunnels are Better than Bridges (2014) by owisd on Sunday June 26, 2022 @05:28AM (#31882377)
The difference Network Rail (the UK's rail infrastructure body) used to distinguish between a tunnel and a bridge was that if it was over 20m long it was a tunnel, but then someone came up with the bright idea to redefine a tunnel as over 30m long, so everything in the 20-30m range would cost less to maintain because bridge engineers were cheaper than tunnel engineers.